A neighbor's garage extends three feet across the boundary. What is this called?
Correct Answer
B) An encroachment on the parcel
Why this is correct: An encroachment is a physical intrusion of a structure (like a building, fence, or garage) onto an adjoining property without permission or legal right. It is unauthorized and can create title issues. This differs from an easement, which is a legal right to use another's land. Why the other choices are wrong: 'An easement in gross over the parcel' is wrong; an easement is a right, not an intrusion. 'A legally nonconforming structure' is wrong; that refers to zoning, not boundary crossing. 'A party wall shared by both owners' is wrong; a party wall is on the boundary line, not across it. Exam tip: Encroachment = unauthorized intrusion. Think 'trespass by a structure'.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
A garage crossing three feet over the line is a structure physically occupying land it has no right to occupy, which is exactly what encroachment means. The absence of any grant, license, or recorded easement is what distinguishes it from authorized uses. For the appraiser the consequence is that the affected area may not be fully usable by the owner of record and the condition should be identified, described, and considered in the value opinion. Whether it can be removed or has ripened into a right is a legal question outside the appraiser's competency.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: An easement in gross over the parcel
An easement in gross is a legal right to use another's land that benefits a person or entity rather than an adjoining parcel, the classic examples being utility and pipeline easements. It is a granted right, usually recorded, and it authorizes use rather than describing an unauthorized intrusion. Calling an unpermitted garage an easement inverts the legal posture, treating a trespass as a right.
Option C: A legally nonconforming structure
A legally nonconforming use or structure is one that lawfully predated a zoning change and is permitted to continue despite no longer complying with current regulations. That concept concerns compliance with public land use rules, not the location of a private boundary line. A structure can be legally nonconforming as to zoning and simultaneously encroaching on a neighbor, since the two questions are entirely independent.
Option D: A party wall shared by both owners
A party wall sits astride a common boundary and is shared by both owners under an agreement or by operation of law, with rights and maintenance obligations running to each. The defining feature is that both owners have rights in it, which is the opposite of an unauthorized one-sided intrusion. The stem describes a garage belonging to one neighbor extending onto the other's land, not a shared structure.
Trespass by Structure
An encroachment is a trespass that cannot walk away. Something physical is standing on land it does not own, with nobody's permission and nothing recorded. Permission would make it a license, a grant would make it an easement.
How to use: Sort boundary items by two questions: is something physically over the line, and did anyone authorize it? Physical plus unauthorized equals encroachment; authorized in writing equals easement; authorized informally equals license.
Exam Tip
Encroachments surface on surveys, not title reports, because they are unrecorded physical facts. Exam items often reward the answer that recommends a survey.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Confusing an encroachment with an easement or a license
- -Assuming a title search would have revealed an unrecorded physical intrusion
- -Rendering a legal conclusion about whether the encroachment has ripened into a right
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
An encroachment is a physical intrusion of a structure or improvement across a boundary onto adjoining land without a legal right to be there. It is distinct from every category of authorized use, because nobody granted permission and no interest was conveyed. Encroachments matter to an appraiser in two directions. On the burdened parcel, the intrusion clouds title, reduces usable area, may complicate a sale or a lender's willingness to finance, and can eventually ripen into a prescriptive easement or even adverse possession if it remains open, notorious, continuous, and hostile for the statutory period. On the encroaching parcel, the owner faces the risk of a suit to compel removal. Encroachments are typically discovered by a boundary survey rather than by a title search, since an unrecorded physical intrusion leaves no paper trail, and the appraiser's proper role is to note the observed condition, disclose it, and recommend that the client obtain a survey and legal advice rather than to opine on the legal outcome.
Background Knowledge
You need the categories of encumbrance and their distinctions: easements appurtenant and in gross, licenses, encroachments, deed restrictions, and liens. You should also know the elements of adverse possession and prescriptive easement, the difference between a title search and a boundary survey, and the Competency Rule limits on offering legal conclusions.
Real-World Application
An appraiser observes a neighbor's garage apparently over the line and finds no easement in the title work. She reports the observed condition, states that no survey was provided, recommends the client obtain one and seek legal advice, and either analyzes the effect on value or, where the extent is unknown, discloses an appropriately stated assumption.
More Land/Site Questions
Under which condition is the land residual technique most applicable?
Why can the same physical parcel carry different values in two assignments?
In a built-up area where no vacant land has sold for years, which approach to site value is the usual fallback?
How is entrepreneurial profit treated in the subdivision development method?
A land comparable sold 18 months ago in a market rising about 4 percent a year. What adjustment direction applies?
Why does a developer's required profit rise for a longer subdivision project?
How does holding cost enter the valuation of land bought for future development?
Excess land is best described as land that has which characteristic?
Plottage value arises in which of the following situations?
Which of the following is an off-site improvement rather than a site improvement?
People Also Study
Real Estate Market
13.6% of exam
Property Description
11.8% of exam
Sales Comparison Approach
16.4% of exam
Cost Approach
13.6% of exam
Income Approach
8.2% of exam