A site is zoned residential but has been used commercially since before the ordinance. What is its status?
Correct Answer
D) A legally nonconforming use that may continue
Why this is correct: A legally nonconforming use (or "grandfathered" use) is one that was lawful when established but does not comply with a subsequently enacted zoning ordinance. It is generally allowed to continue subject to local regulations. Why the other choices are wrong: 'An illegal use subject to immediate abatement' is wrong; a legally nonconforming use is not illegal. 'A use requiring an annual special permit' describes a conditional use, not a nonconforming use. 'A use that a variance has already authorized' is incorrect; a variance grants permission to deviate from zoning, while a nonconforming use predates the zoning change. Exam tip: A legally nonconforming use is a property right, but its value is affected by local rules on expansion, repair, and abandonment.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
A use lawful when established and made non-compliant by a later ordinance is legally nonconforming and may generally continue, subject to limits on expansion, change and rebuilding.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: An illegal use subject to immediate abatement
A use lawful when established is not illegal. Abatement applies to uses that never had lawful status.
Option B: A use requiring an annual special permit
Nonconforming status attaches by operation of the ordinance and does not require an annual permit.
Option C: A use that a variance has already authorized
A variance is separately granted relief from a zoning requirement. Nonconforming status arises automatically from the sequence of events.
Lawful Then, Protected Now
Lawful Then, Protected Now — but frozen. No expanding, no changing, and use it or lose it.
How to use: Investigate the limits rather than assuming continuation. Rebuilding and discontinuance provisions vary widely.
Exam Tip
Discontinuance periods are the trap. A vacant nonconforming property can lose its status while nobody is watching.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Treating the use as illegal
- -Confusing nonconforming status with a variance
- -Assuming the use could be rebuilt or expanded
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
A legally nonconforming use — commonly called grandfathered — arises where a use was lawful when established and was made non-compliant by a later zoning change. Zoning ordinances almost universally allow such uses to continue, because terminating them would take value the owner lawfully created. But the protection is limited in ways that matter to an appraiser. The use generally may not be expanded or intensified, cannot usually be changed to a different nonconforming use, and typically may not be rebuilt if destroyed beyond a threshold percentage of value. Most consequentially, the right is usually lost if the use is discontinued for a stated period — often six months to a year — after which the property reverts to conforming uses only. Those limitations affect financing, insurance and value, and they must be investigated rather than assumed. The status also feeds directly into the highest and best use analysis, since the legally permissible test asks what may lawfully continue as well as what may lawfully begin.
Background Knowledge
A legally nonconforming use was lawful when established and became non-compliant through a later zoning change. Such uses may generally continue but typically cannot be expanded, changed or rebuilt after substantial destruction, and may be lost through discontinuance.
Real-World Application
An appraiser confirms a commercial use predates the residential zoning, checks the ordinance's rebuilding and discontinuance provisions, and reports the status and its limits.
More land-or-site-valuation Questions
Under which condition is the land residual technique most applicable?
What is the appraiser's obligation when a site's legal description does not match its apparent physical boundaries?
Why can the same physical parcel carry different values in two assignments?
A site differs from land in that a site is best described as which of the following?
In a built-up area where no vacant land has sold for years, which approach to site value is the usual fallback?
How is entrepreneurial profit treated in the subdivision development method?
A land comparable sold 18 months ago in a market rising about 4 percent a year. What adjustment direction applies?
In a land residual analysis for a proposed office development, the appraiser estimates total annual net operating income (NOI) will be $1,250,000. The improvement value, derived via the cost approach, is $15,000,000. Market evidence indicates a 7.0% overall capitalization rate is appropriate for similar improved properties. What is the indicated land value?
A developer plans a 36-lot residential subdivision on raw land. Each lot is expected to sell for $85,000. Total development costs (excluding land) are $1,420,000, including $220,000 for entrepreneurial incentive. The developer requires a 12% annual yield on invested capital over a 3-year development period. Using the subdivision development method, what is the maximum price the developer should pay for the land if all lots sell at the projected price and timing?
In applying the land residual technique to a proposed subdivision, an appraiser estimates that the time required to fully absorb all lots will be 6 years. The developer requires a 10% annual yield on invested capital. Which discounting approach is most appropriate for converting future net proceeds to present value?
People Also Study
Valuation Principles & Procedures
25% of exam
Property Description & Analysis
20% of exam
Market Analysis & Highest/Best Use
15% of exam
Appraisal Math & Statistics
15% of exam
USPAP (Ethics & Standards)
15% of exam