A service station has operated on the same site for fifty years. The surrounding corridor has since shifted to newer retail, and the station's sales have been falling. What does this history mean for its highest and best use?
Correct Answer
D) The existing use is a starting point, but economic change means it must be tested again
Because owners tend to develop property to its highest and best use, the existing use is often the highest and best use, but not always. Properties stay in one use for long periods while economic change can make that use less profitable or obsolete, so highest and best use changes over time and must be tested as of the appraisal date. A long history or the original decision to build does not settle it, and a corridor trend alone does not establish a new use without testing.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Option D is correct because the existing use is often, but not always, the highest and best use. The corridor's shift and the falling sales show economic change that may have made the station less profitable, so the appraiser must test the use again as of the appraisal date.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: The fifty-year history establishes the station as the highest and best use for this appraisal
Option A says fifty years of operation establish the station as the highest and best use. Long use shows the station was once a sound choice, but properties stay in one use for long periods while economic change can make that use less profitable.
Option B: The highest and best use was fixed when the station was built and stays fixed while it stands
Option B says the highest and best use was fixed at construction and stays fixed while the building stands. Highest and best use changes over time, and the as-improved analysis can conclude that an existing building should be converted or replaced.
Option C: Retail redevelopment is the highest and best use, since the corridor has shifted to retail
Option C concludes that retail redevelopment is the highest and best use because the corridor has shifted. The shift is a reason to test alternatives, but redevelopment must still pass the legal, physical, feasibility and productivity tests before it can be concluded.
Old use, fresh test
However long a use has lasted, it gets a fresh highest and best use test on each appraisal date.
How to use: Use this phrase when a stem stresses how long a property has been in its current use.
Exam Tip
Treat the existing use as a likely answer, not an automatic one. Signals of market change in the stem call for retesting.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Assuming a long-standing use remains the highest and best use
- -Relying on the owner's past results instead of current market evidence
- -Thinking highest and best use is fixed at construction
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
The question tests whether the existing use can be assumed to be the highest and best use. The existing use is a reasonable starting point, but the stem signals economic change, which calls for the four tests to be applied as of the appraisal date.
Background Knowledge
Since buyers and owners generally try to maximize value, the existing use is likely to be the highest and best use, but economic change can make a long-standing use less profitable or obsolete. Highest and best use is concluded as of the effective date of the appraisal.
Real-World Application
An appraiser values an old gas station on a corridor where big-box retail has replaced most older uses. Rather than assume continued fuel sales, the appraiser compares continued use with conversion and redevelopment, using current market data.
More Market Questions
In market area analysis, what characteristic distinguishes a district from a neighborhood?
Under USPAP Standards Rule 1-3(a), which item must an appraiser identify and analyze when necessary for credible results in a market value assignment?
How does the Fannie Mae Selling Guide define a neighborhood?
Several homes in a neighborhood are vacant and boarded up. Which market force does Fannie Mae classify this as?
Infrastructure investment such as a new interchange typically affects nearby land by:
A city raises property tax rates and tightens building regulations. Which market force does Fannie Mae classify these as?
An appraiser believes, without market evidence, that a nearby group home lowers values. What does Fannie Mae require?
Which three categories are used to report the supply of properties in a Fannie Mae neighborhood section?
An appraiser is asked for a retrospective value opinion as of three years ago. When must the appraiser meet the Competency Rule?
Can mixed land uses in a residential neighborhood ever enhance home values, according to Fannie Mae?
People Also Study
Property Description
11.8% of exam
Land or Site Valuation
4.5% of exam
Sales Comparison Approach
16.4% of exam
Cost Approach
13.6% of exam
Income Approach
8.2% of exam
Previous Question
According to USPAP’s definition of value, how is value always described in appraisal practice?
Next Question
An institution is financing a building leased long term to a highly rated tenant at contract rent below market rent, and the leased fee interest is being appraised. Under the Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, which market value should be used?