A rural tract can be leased for sand extraction that yields a very high annual income but exhausts the deposit and leaves the land of little use within three years, or planted as an orchard that yields lower but sustained income. Both uses are legal, physically possible and financially feasible. Which use is the highest and best use?
Correct Answer
A) The use that produces the higher land value over a reasonable period
Among feasible uses, the most productive is the one producing the highest land value, generally the most profitable over a reasonable period of time. A use that yields high current income but quickly depletes the property may not be the highest and best use, so the appraiser must test whether the sustained orchard income produces the higher land value. Option B judges by current income alone, option C ignores land value, and option D stops at the feasibility test.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Option A is correct because the most productive use is the feasible use that produces the highest land value, generally over a reasonable period of time. A sustained orchard income can produce a higher land value than a short burst of extraction income that leaves the land of little use.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option B: Sand extraction, because it produces the highest current annual income from the tract
Option B picks sand extraction for its highest current annual income. A use that yields very high current income but quickly depletes the property may not be the highest and best use, because land value reflects benefits over time.
Option C: The use with the lower risk, even if it produces the lower land value of the two
Option C picks the lower-risk use even if it produces the lower land value. Risk is reflected in a risk-adjusted land value comparison; it does not override that comparison.
Option D: Both uses equally, because each one passes the financially feasible test
Option D treats both uses as equal because each is financially feasible. Feasibility only qualifies uses for the final test, which selects the feasible use that produces the highest land value.
Marathon can beat the sprint
A use that sprints with high income and then collapses may lose to a steady use that keeps earning, once both are measured as land value.
How to use: Use this image when a stem contrasts a depleting high-income use with a lower, sustained one.
Exam Tip
Highest current income is not the test. Look for the option that measures land value over a reasonable period.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Choosing the use with the highest current income
- -Stopping at the feasibility test
- -Ignoring the condition of the land after a depleting use ends
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
The question tests the maximally productive test when one use depletes the property. High current income is not the measure; land value over a reasonable period is. The answer leaves room for either use but states the right standard.
Background Knowledge
The maximally productive test picks, among financially feasible uses, the one producing the highest land value on a risk-adjusted basis. It is generally the use that is most profitable over a reasonable period, so a depleting use with high early income must be compared with a sustained use.
Real-World Application
An appraiser values farmland where a quarry operator has offered a short, lucrative extraction lease. The appraiser compares the land value from extraction, including the poor condition of the land afterward, with the land value from continued farming.
More Market Questions
In market area analysis, what characteristic distinguishes a district from a neighborhood?
Under USPAP Standards Rule 1-3(a), which item must an appraiser identify and analyze when necessary for credible results in a market value assignment?
How does the Fannie Mae Selling Guide define a neighborhood?
Several homes in a neighborhood are vacant and boarded up. Which market force does Fannie Mae classify this as?
Infrastructure investment such as a new interchange typically affects nearby land by:
A city raises property tax rates and tightens building regulations. Which market force does Fannie Mae classify these as?
An appraiser believes, without market evidence, that a nearby group home lowers values. What does Fannie Mae require?
Which three categories are used to report the supply of properties in a Fannie Mae neighborhood section?
An appraiser is asked for a retrospective value opinion as of three years ago. When must the appraiser meet the Competency Rule?
Can mixed land uses in a residential neighborhood ever enhance home values, according to Fannie Mae?
People Also Study
Property Description
11.8% of exam
Land or Site Valuation
4.5% of exam
Sales Comparison Approach
16.4% of exam
Cost Approach
13.6% of exam
Income Approach
8.2% of exam