A jurisdictional exception in USPAP allows an appraiser to:
Correct Answer
B) Comply with conflicting law, and disclose having done so
Why this is correct: A jurisdictional exception in USPAP (see the Jurisdictional Exception Rule) allows an appraiser to comply with specific laws or regulations that conflict with USPAP, provided the appraiser identifies the law and discloses the exception in the assignment. Why the other choices are wrong: 'Use non-USPAP standards where they are more appropriate' is not allowed; USPAP is the minimum standard. 'Comply with client instructions that override USPAP rules' is prohibited; client instructions cannot override USPAP. 'Ignore any USPAP rule that conflicts with state law' is too broad; the exception requires specific identification and disclosure. Exam tip: Jurisdictional Exception = Comply with conflicting LAW, disclose it. It's not for client preferences.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Option B correctly identifies that jurisdictional exceptions allow compliance with legal requirements that conflict with USPAP, but emphasizes the critical requirement for proper disclosure. The exception is narrowly defined and can only be invoked when there is an actual legal requirement that creates a direct conflict with USPAP standards. The appraiser must clearly identify the legal requirement, explain how it conflicts with USPAP, and disclose this exception in the appraisal report. This maintains transparency while allowing appraisers to comply with mandatory legal obligations.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: Use non-USPAP standards where they are more appropriate
Option A is too broad and incorrect because it suggests appraisers can ignore 'any' USPAP requirement that conflicts with state law, which overstates the scope of jurisdictional exceptions. The exception is much more limited and requires specific conditions to be met, including proper disclosure and documentation.
Option C: Follow client instructions that override USPAP rules
Option C is incorrect because jurisdictional exceptions are not about using alternative standards that might be 'more appropriate' - this would be a matter of professional judgment, not legal compliance. The exception only applies when there is a mandatory legal requirement that creates a direct conflict with USPAP.
Option D: Ignore any USPAP rule that conflicts with state law
Option D is completely wrong because client instructions or preferences can never override USPAP requirements through a jurisdictional exception. The exception is strictly limited to legal mandates from governmental authorities, not client demands or commercial pressures.
LEGAL-D Rule
LEGAL-D: Legal requirements only, Explicitly disclosed, Government mandate, Actual conflict, Limited scope, Documented properly. Remember that jurisdictional exceptions are for LEGAL conflicts only, and must always be DISCLOSED.
How to use: When you see a jurisdictional exception question, immediately think 'LEGAL-D' and eliminate any answer choices that involve client preferences, convenience, or alternative methodologies. Look for the answer that emphasizes both legal requirements AND proper disclosure.
Exam Tip
On exam day, remember that jurisdictional exceptions have two key requirements: (1) an actual legal mandate that conflicts with USPAP, and (2) proper disclosure of the exception. Any answer choice missing either element is likely incorrect.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Thinking client instructions can create a jurisdictional exception
- -Believing the exception allows ignoring any USPAP requirement without disclosure
- -Confusing jurisdictional exceptions with supplemental standards or alternative methodologies
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
A jurisdictional exception in USPAP is a narrow provision that allows appraisers to comply with legal requirements that directly conflict with specific USPAP standards, but only under very strict conditions. This exception recognizes that appraisers must follow applicable laws and regulations in their jurisdiction, even when those laws conflict with USPAP requirements. The exception requires proper identification and disclosure of the conflict, and it cannot be used for client preferences or convenience. It is specifically limited to legal mandates, not professional judgment calls or alternative methodologies.
Background Knowledge
USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice) is the generally accepted standard for appraisal practice in the United States, but appraisers must also comply with federal, state, and local laws. When these legal requirements directly conflict with specific USPAP provisions, the jurisdictional exception provides a narrow pathway for compliance while maintaining professional standards through disclosure requirements.
Real-World Application
In practice, a jurisdictional exception might occur when state law requires a specific valuation method for tax assessment purposes that conflicts with USPAP's requirements for highest and best use analysis. The appraiser would need to follow the state law but must clearly disclose this exception and explain how it differs from standard USPAP requirements in the appraisal report.
More USPAP Questions
Which statement best defines a hypothetical condition under USPAP?
According to the Competency Rule, if an appraiser lacks the knowledge and experience to complete an assignment competently, which action is NOT acceptable?
An appraiser runs only the sales comparison approach on a standard tract home and omits the cost and income approaches. Under Standard 1 this is:
A value opinion for a subdivision as if fully built out two years from now is what kind of assignment, and what does it require?
A hypothetical condition differs from an extraordinary assumption in that a hypothetical condition:
An appraiser must disclose in the certification whether they have:
A client-imposed requirement — 'use only comps from our approved list' — is best described as:
Under Standard 1, when developing a real property appraisal, an appraiser must:
The certification required by Standards Rule 2-3 must be signed by:
According to Standard 1, when developing an opinion of market value, an appraiser must analyze:
People Also Study
Real Estate Market
13.6% of exam
Property Description
11.8% of exam
Land or Site Valuation
4.5% of exam
Sales Comparison Approach
16.4% of exam
Cost Approach
13.6% of exam