Income Approachhard8.2% of exam

A certified general appraiser is valuing a regional shopping center subject to long-term triple-net leases. One anchor tenant occupies 40% of the GLA under a 12-year lease with fixed annual rent of $1.2 million; the remaining space is leased to smaller tenants at market rates, with rents projected to grow at 2.5% per year. The appraiser develops a discounted cash flow model with a 10-year holding period. Which statement best reflects the appropriate treatment of the anchor tenant’s rent in the DCF model?

Correct Answer

C) The anchor rent must be included as a fixed cash flow for 10 years, and the reversion must reflect the value of the space at market rent after lease expiration.

Per USPAP Standards Rule 1-4(b) and the Appraisal Institute’s *The Appraisal of Real Estate* (15th ed., Ch. 17), a DCF model must reflect the actual or anticipated cash flows over the holding period, including contractual rents, and the reversion must represent the property’s value at the end of the holding period assuming market conditions — i.e., vacant and available for lease at market rent. Excluding contractual rent (B, D) or capitalizing it separately (A) violates the integrated nature of DCF. Option C correctly incorporates the fixed rent during the holding period and recognizes that the reversion assumes market rent for the entire property post-holding period.

Answer Options

The anchor rent must be capitalized separately using a fee-simple yield rate and added to the DCF value of the remainder.

The anchor rent should be excluded from the DCF because it is below market and creates a leasehold interest.

The anchor rent must be included as a fixed cash flow for 10 years, and the reversion must reflect the value of the space at market rent after lease expiration.

Only the market-rate rents may be included in the DCF; the anchor rent is irrelevant because it is contractually fixed.

Why This Is the Correct Answer

Including the anchor rent as a fixed cash flow for all ten years mirrors the legal reality that the lease binds the tenant at that rent through year twelve. Reflecting market rent in the reversion mirrors the equally real fact that a buyer at the end of the holding period is pricing the space for what it will command once the lease approaches or reaches expiration. The two halves together are what a DCF is for: it separates the certain contractual period from the uncertain post-lease period rather than forcing one rent assumption across the whole life. It also correctly keeps everything inside a single integrated model.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Option A: The anchor rent must be capitalized separately using a fee-simple yield rate and added to the DCF value of the remainder.

Splitting the anchor out and capitalizing it separately with a fee simple yield rate breaks the DCF into two inconsistent valuations and misapplies the interest being appraised, since a property encumbered by leases is a leased fee, not fee simple. It also double-handles the reversion, because the anchor space is part of what the buyer acquires at the end of the holding period. Bifurcation of this kind is sometimes seen in credit-tenant lease analysis, which is what makes it sound sophisticated, but it is not how a whole-property DCF is built.

Option B: The anchor rent should be excluded from the DCF because it is below market and creates a leasehold interest.

Nothing in the facts says the anchor rent is below market, and even if it were, a below-market contract rent does not create a leasehold interest in the appraiser's model, it simply reduces the value of the leased fee. Excluding a real, contractually binding income stream from a cash flow model guarantees an understated value. The confusion here is between a leasehold advantage held by a tenant and the appraisal of the landlord's leased fee position.

Option D: Only the market-rate rents may be included in the DCF; the anchor rent is irrelevant because it is contractually fixed.

Calling contract rent irrelevant because it is fixed inverts the logic: fixed rent is the most certain cash flow in the model, not the least relevant. If only market-rate space were modeled, forty percent of the gross leasable area would produce no income for ten years, which no buyer would accept. The option appeals to candidates who remember that market value rests on market rent and forget that a leased fee is valued on the rent the leases actually deliver.

Contract Now, Market Later

Draw a timeline and put a wall at the end of the holding period. Everything left of the wall is what the leases say. Everything at and beyond the wall is what the market says. The reversion is the wall.

How to use: For any DCF question, first check whether the lease term outlasts the holding period. If it does, contract rent fills every projection year and market rent only shows up in the reversion; if the lease expires mid-model, market rent enters at rollover along with downtime and releasing costs.

Exam Tip

Compare the lease expiration to the holding period before reading the choices. That one comparison usually eliminates two options immediately.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

-Substituting market rent for contract rent during a lease that is still in force
-Forgetting to reflect market rent and releasing costs in the reversion
-Using the going-in capitalization rate as the terminal rate without considering the property's added age at resale

Concept Deep Dive

Analysis

A discounted cash flow model values a property by projecting the actual cash the property will generate during a defined holding period and then adding the present value of the reversion, which is what the property is worth when the holding period ends. In a leased-fee valuation, the cash flows during the holding period are the contract rents the leases actually obligate tenants to pay, not what the appraiser wishes the space would rent for. The anchor's $1.2 million fixed rent runs for twelve years, which outlasts the ten-year holding period, so all ten years of the model carry that fixed number while the smaller tenant rents escalate at 2.5 percent. The reversion is where market rent re-enters: it is typically derived by capitalizing the eleventh-year net operating income at a terminal rate, with that income reflecting market conditions and market rent as leases roll. Getting the item right means seeing that contract rent controls the near term and market rent controls the exit.

Background Knowledge

You need the difference between fee simple and leased fee interests, and the rule that leased fee valuation uses contract rent during the lease term and market rent thereafter. You should also know the parts of a DCF: projected net operating income by year, a discount rate, a holding period, and a reversion normally derived with a terminal capitalization rate applied to the year-after income.

Real-World Application

An appraiser modeling a regional center holds the anchor's flat rent constant through year ten, escalates inline shop rents, builds in vacancy and collection loss plus tenant improvement and leasing commission costs at each shop rollover, and derives the reversion by capitalizing year eleven net operating income at a terminal rate slightly above the going-in rate, then deducts costs of sale.

discounted cash flowleased fee interestcontract rent versus market rentreversion and terminal cap rate

Was this explanation helpful?

People Also Study

Real Estate Market

13.6% of exam

Property Description

11.8% of exam

Land or Site Valuation

4.5% of exam

Sales Comparison Approach

16.4% of exam

Cost Approach

13.6% of exam

Previous Question

When analyzing income and expense data for a multi-tenant office building to develop an opinion of market value, an appraiser includes revenue from parking fees collected by the owner. In the appraiser's income and expense analysis, these parking fees should be treated as part of:

Next Question

Direct capitalization differs from yield capitalization (DCF) in that direct cap:

Income Approach Questions Practice Interactively