What background knowledge is needed for this Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act question?

The disparate impact theory in fair housing law was developed through decades of case law and was affirmed by the U.S. Supreme Court in Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs v. Inclusive Communities Project (2015). HUD's guidance on national origin discrimination in housing, including guidance on the use of alternative identification documents, reflects the reality of America's diverse immigrant population. Pennsylvania's Human Relations Commission has similarly recognized that policies with unjustified disparate impacts on protected classes can constitute unlawful discrimination under 43 P.S. §955.

What is a good way to remember the answer to this Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act question?

Use the 'Neutral ≠ Fair' principle: visualize a scale that looks perfectly balanced but is secretly weighted on one side. The Social Security number requirement looks balanced (it applies to everyone) but is secretly weighted against certain national origin groups. Whenever you see a 'neutral' policy on the exam, ask: 'Does this disproportionately exclude a protected class?' If yes, it may be disparate impact discrimination.

What exam tip applies to this Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act question?

Questions involving disparate impact are among the most nuanced on fair housing exams. The key signal words are 'disproportionately,' 'may constitute,' and 'most likely' — these indicate the question is testing disparate impact analysis rather than clear-cut intentional discrimination. Look for the answer that acknowledges the potential for discrimination based on effect, not just intent. Answer C's language ('may constitute' and 'most likely') correctly reflects the legal standard of disparate impact analysis.

How does this Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act concept apply in real world practice?

A large apartment complex in Philadelphia requires all applicants to provide a Social Security number on the application form and rejects any application that cannot provide one. A lawful permanent resident from Vietnam who has an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) and valid government-issued photo ID is denied solely because she lacks a Social Security number. She files a complaint with the PHRC, arguing that the policy disproportionately excludes applicants from certain national origins. The landlord must now demonstrate that the policy is necessary and that no less discriminatory alternative (such as accepting ITINs) is available.

Pa Fair Housing Human Relations ActFederal_fha_paMEDIUM

An apartment complex in Pennsylvania requires all applicants to provide a Social Security number as part of the application process. An applicant who is a lawful permanent resident with valid documentation but no Social Security number is denied. Under fair housing law, this requirement MOST likely:

Correct Answer

C) May constitute national origin discrimination if it disproportionately excludes applicants of certain nationalities

While requiring identification is generally permissible, a blanket requirement for a Social Security number may have a disparate impact on applicants of certain national origins, particularly immigrants who are lawfully present but may not yet have a Social Security number. This could constitute national origin discrimination under the PA Human Relations Act (43 P.S. §955).

Answer Options

Is unlawful because landlords cannot require any identification documents

Is lawful because requiring identification is a standard business practice

May constitute national origin discrimination if it disproportionately excludes applicants of certain nationalities

Is lawful because immigration status is not a protected class under the PA Human Relations Act

Why This Is the Correct Answer

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Deep Analysis of This Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act Question

Background Knowledge for Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act

Real World Application in Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act

Common Mistakes to Avoid on Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act Questions

Related Concepts

Market Allocation

Market allocation is an illegal antitrust practice in which competing real estate brokerages agree to divide markets among themselves by geographic area, property type, or price range, thereby eliminating competition.

Price Fixing

Price fixing is an illegal antitrust practice in which competing real estate brokerages agree to charge the same commission rates, fees, or other pricing for their services. It is a per se violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act.

Record Keeping Requirements

Florida brokers are required to maintain transaction records and escrow records for a minimum of five years.

Was this explanation helpful?

More Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act Questions

Under the PA Human Relations Act, all of the following actions by a landlord would violate fair housing law EXCEPT:

A landlord in Pennsylvania owns a duplex and lives in one unit. The landlord refuses to rent the other unit to a family because of their race. The landlord did not use a real estate agent or discriminatory advertising. Under fair housing law, is this landlord's action lawful?

Under the PA Human Relations Act, the PHRC is composed of commissioners appointed by which official?

If the PHRC and a respondent in a housing discrimination case reach a successful conciliation agreement, the agreement typically includes:

A real estate agent in Pennsylvania is found by the PHRC to have engaged in steering based on race. In addition to PHRC remedies, the SREC considers disciplinary action. Under RELA, fair housing violations may result in which of the following SREC sanctions?

People Also Study

Buyer Representation Agreement

8% of exam

Property Ownership

10% of exam

Land Use Controls and Regulations

8% of exam

Valuation and Market Analysis

10% of exam

Real Estate Exam Pass Rates by State: 2026 Data Report

Last updated: March 2026 | Sources: State licensing boards, ARELLO, Bureau of Labor Statistics

What to Do When Your Real Estate Exam Study Plan Looks Good on Paper but Keeps Slipping

If you are searching for real estate exam study plan keeps slipping , the practical answer is usually more useful than a motivational one. The biggest...

How to Prepare for the Real Estate Exam If You Learn Better by Writing Things Out

If you are searching for how to prepare for real estate exam by writing notes , the practical answer is usually more useful than a motivational one. The...

Previous Question

A tenant in a Pennsylvania apartment complex requests that the landlord waive the building's 'no guests after 10 PM' rule because her live-in aide, who assists with her disability, arrives at 11 PM due to the aide's other work commitments. Under the PA Human Relations Act, the landlord should:

Next Question

A property management company in Pennsylvania uses an algorithm to screen rental applicants. The algorithm considers zip codes as a factor, which results in applicants from predominantly minority neighborhoods being rejected at a higher rate. Under the PA Human Relations Act, this screening practice:

Pa Fair Housing Human Relations Act Questions