Dale is selling a 320-acre farm in Brookings County, South Dakota. The property includes a creek that runs along the northern boundary, and Dale has held a state-issued water permit for irrigation use for the past 15 years. A buyer from Minnesota assumes the water rights will automatically transfer with the land deed. Under South Dakota law, which of the following statements is most accurate regarding Dale's disclosure obligations?
Correct Answer
A) Dale must disclose the existence and status of the water permit because South Dakota follows the prior appropriation doctrine, and water rights do not automatically transfer with the land.
South Dakota follows the prior appropriation doctrine for surface water rights under SDCL Chapter 46-1 through 46-6. Under this doctrine, water rights are separate from land ownership and do not automatically transfer with the deed. The existence, status, and transferability of the irrigation permit are material facts that Dale must disclose to the buyer. Failure to disclose the water rights situation in a rural or agricultural transaction can constitute a material omission and expose the seller and licensee to liability.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Deep Analysis of This Mandated Disclosures Question
Background Knowledge for Mandated Disclosures
Real World Application in Mandated Disclosures
Common Mistakes to Avoid on Mandated Disclosures Questions
Related Topics & Key Terms
Key Terms:
Related Concepts
A seller's disclosure statement is a form that sellers complete to inform buyers about the condition and history of the property, including known defects, past repairs, insurance claims, and environmental issues.
Many states and localities have fair housing laws that expand upon the protections offered by the federal Fair Housing Act.
A stigmatized property is one that has an undesirable reputation due to events that occurred on the property or nearby, such as a murder, suicide, alleged haunting, or proximity to a registered sex offender. The stigma is psychological, not physical.
More Mandated Disclosures Questions
In Vermont, a client refuses to allow a disclosure the licensee believes is necessary. Which statement is correct?
In Vermont, unpermitted construction or septic work affects a Vermont property. Which statement is correct?
A Vermont licensee is asked about a seller's agent knows a serious property defect or limitation. What is the best answer?
In Vermont, a licensee markets a pre-1978 Vermont residential rental property. Which statement is correct?
In Vermont, a seller's agent knows a serious property defect or limitation. Which statement is correct?
- → In Vermont, covered pre-1978 property is shown to a buyer. Which statement is correct?
- → In Vermont, the property is subject to a right of first refusal. Which statement is correct?
- → A Vermont licensee is asked about unpermitted construction or septic work affects a Vermont property. What is the best answer?
- → An Oklahoma licensee is asked about a seller learns of a new defect after already delivering a disclosure or disclaimer statement. What is the best answer?
- → Which Oklahoma rule applies when a seller wants to use the Oklahoma disclaimer statement instead of a disclosure statement?
- → An Oklahoma licensee is asked about a seller of covered Oklahoma residential property is preparing for a buyer’s offer. What is the best answer?
- → In Oklahoma real estate practice, a seller has not yet accepted a purchaser’s offer. What should the licensee remember?
- → For the Oklahoma salesperson state portion, a disclosure statement is delivered after an offer to purchase has been made. Which statement is correct?
- → Which Oklahoma rule applies when a real estate licensee actually knows of a property defect that is not included in the seller’s disclosure statement?
- → In Oklahoma real estate practice, a newly constructed dwelling has never been occupied. What should the licensee remember?