EstatePass
Property Ownership Land Use ControlsEncumbrances_and_liensMEDIUM

A developer in California records a set of deed restrictions (CC&Rs) for a new subdivision that prohibit any lot from being used for commercial purposes. Twenty years later, the surrounding area has become entirely commercial, and the subdivision is the only remaining residential area. A lot owner wants to open a retail store. Under California law, what doctrine might allow the court to refuse enforcement of the restriction?

Correct Answer

A) Changed conditions doctrine, because the neighborhood has fundamentally changed character

Under California law, the changed conditions doctrine allows a court to refuse enforcement of a restrictive covenant when the neighborhood has changed so substantially that the restriction no longer serves its original purpose. If the surrounding area has become entirely commercial, a court may find that enforcing the residential-only restriction would be inequitable and serve no purpose.

Answer Options
A
Changed conditions doctrine, because the neighborhood has fundamentally changed character
B
Adverse possession, because the surrounding commercial use negates the restriction
C
Estoppel, because the HOA failed to enforce the restriction against commercial neighbors
D
Prescription, because the commercial activity has occurred for more than five years

Why This Is the Correct Answer

Under California law, the changed conditions doctrine allows a court to refuse enforcement of a restrictive covenant when the neighborhood has changed so substantially that the restriction no longer serves its original purpose. If the surrounding area has become entirely commercial, a court may find that enforcing the residential-only restriction would be inequitable and serve no purpose.

Interactive lesson · Chapter 24 of 30 · Land use controls

Private controls

Private land use controls are created by owners, not by government: a restriction written into a deed, or a declaration of covenants, conditions and restrictions (CC&Rs) recorded for a whole subdivision and commonly administered by a homeowners association. Restrictive covenants run with the land and bind later owners. They are enforced by the people they benefit, the other lot owners or the association, in court, usually by an injunction. When zoning and a private restriction both apply and differ, the more restrictive governs.

ZoningCovenantsWhat may be built
Both apply; neither cancels the otherThe more restrictive limit governsA covenant that discriminates is unenforceable
Two setback lines on one lot, and who enforces each

Chapters 1–3 are free in full, practice sets included.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Deep Analysis of This Property Ownership Land Use Controls Question

Background Knowledge for Property Ownership Land Use Controls

Memory Technique

Exam Tip for Property Ownership Land Use Controls

Real World Application in Property Ownership Land Use Controls

Common Mistakes to Avoid on Property Ownership Land Use Controls Questions

Related Topics & Key Terms

Key Terms:

deed_restrictionschanged_conditionsCC&Rsenforcement

Related Concepts

A conditional use permit (also called a special use permit) allows a land use that is not automatically permitted by zoning but may be allowed under certain conditions. The use must be compatible with the surrounding area.

Deed restrictions are limitations placed in a deed that control how a property may be used by the current and future owners. They are a form of private land use control that runs with the land.

An easement is a legal right to use another person's land for a specific purpose without owning it. It is a nonpossessory interest in real property that typically runs with the land.

Was this explanation helpful?

More Property Ownership Land Use Controls Questions

People Also Study

Related Articles

Practice More Questions

Access 2,000+ practice questions and pass your real estate exam.

Start Practicing