In a consumer-credit transaction secured by the consumer’s principal dwelling, a borrower questions a $650 appraisal fee after seeing $400 quotes. What analysis is appropriate under Regulation Z 1026.42(f)?
Correct Answer
B) Assess comparable-service market rates and relevant assignment/appraiser factors
For a covered Regulation Z transaction, 1026.42(f) asks whether the creditor and its agents compensate the fee appraiser at a rate that is customary and reasonable for comparable services in the relevant geographic market, considering the listed assignment and appraiser factors. Two lower quotes alone prove neither a violation nor the correct fee, and splitting the difference has no regulatory basis. Legitimate fee negotiation is not automatically coercion.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Option B is correct because 1026.42(f) asks whether the creditor and its agents pay a rate that is customary and reasonable for comparable appraisal services in the property's geographic market. Once recent market rates are identified, the creditor or its agent must review the listed factors to determine the appropriate rate for the transaction. That is a market-and-factors analysis, not a comparison to a pair of quotes.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: Split the difference between the two at $525
Option A splits the difference between $650 and $400 to arrive at $525, calculated as ($650 + $400) / 2. That arithmetic has no regulatory basis; the rule looks to comparable-service market rates and the listed factors.
Option C: Treat the lowest quote as the required legal fee
Option C treats the lowest quote of $400 as the required legal fee, but the rule sets no fee from the lowest quote. A customary and reasonable rate depends on comparable services in the market and the relevant assignment and appraiser factors.
Option D: Assume each fee negotiation between lender and appraiser violates appraiser independence
Option D assumes each fee negotiation between lender and appraiser violates appraiser independence. Legitimate fee negotiation is not automatically coercion; the question is whether the resulting rate is customary and reasonable.
Market first, then factors
Find what comparable appraisals pay in that market, then adjust for the specific assignment and appraiser factors.
How to use: Use this two-step order whenever a question asks how to judge whether an appraisal fee is customary and reasonable.
Exam Tip
Answers that set a fee by averaging quotes or picking the lowest number are shortcuts; prefer the answer that reviews market rates for comparable services and the listed factors.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Treating the lowest available quote as the legal fee
- -Averaging quotes as if that satisfied the rule
- -Assuming any fee negotiation is coercion
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
This question tests how a customary-and-reasonable fee is evaluated under Regulation Z 1026.42(f). Two lower quotes do not settle the issue by themselves. The rule calls for identifying recent rates for comparable services in the geographic market and then reviewing the listed assignment and appraiser factors.
Background Knowledge
Under Regulation Z, the customary-and-reasonable analysis begins with recent rates for comparable appraisal services in the geographic market. Factors such as the type of property, scope of work, time frame, and the appraiser's qualifications and experience then inform the appropriate rate for the specific assignment.
Real-World Application
A borrower complains that a $650 fee is too high after seeing online quotes for $400. The lender's AMC reviews recent fees paid for comparable appraisals in that county and notes that the subject is a complex rural property, which supports a higher rate.
More USPAP Questions
An appraiser signs, finalizes and electronically transmits a residential appraisal report to the client on March 15. Its value opinion has a March 1 effective date. The client does not open the transmitted report until March 20. What is the report date?
The Dodd-Frank Act's appraisal provisions primarily focus on:
According to AQB criteria, what is the minimum number of classroom hours of qualifying education required for a Certified Residential appraiser?
In a Fannie Mae appraisal, which item does not belong in the appraiser's site analysis?
After delivering a $485,000 URAR, an appraiser discovers a previously undisclosed $15,000 seller repair credit on a comparable sale that may materially change the analysis. What is the most appropriate response?
The special appraisal requirements in Regulation Z §1026.35(c), adopted under Dodd-Frank, concern which covered mortgage category?
A state appraiser regulatory agency is reviewing an appraiser's continuing education compliance. The appraiser completed 28 hours of continuing education in the current two-year period, including 5 hours of USPAP update training. Does this meet AQB requirements?
According to USPAP Standard 2, which of the following is NOT a required element in an appraisal report?
A client asks an appraiser to raise a completed report’s value conclusion by $15,000 solely to match the contract price, without providing new evidence. What should the appraiser do?
A comparable-sale grid includes a $5,000 bathroom adjustment. Which treatment best supports clear appraisal reporting?
People Also Study
Real Estate Market
13.6% of exam
Property Description
11.8% of exam
Land or Site Valuation
4.5% of exam
Sales Comparison Approach
16.4% of exam
Cost Approach
13.6% of exam