EstatePass
Practice Of Real EstateState SpecificHARD

A tenant in Carmel signs a two-year lease and pays a $1,500 security deposit. After 18 months, the landlord and tenant mutually agree to terminate the lease early. The tenant vacates and delivers possession on April 10. The landlord does not return the deposit or provide any written statement. On June 30, the tenant demands the full deposit back. The landlord argues that because the early termination was mutual, the standard 45-day rule does not apply. Which of the following best describes the legal outcome under Indiana law?

Correct Answer

B) The landlord must return the full deposit because the 45-day deadline passed on May 25, and the landlord forfeited all deduction rights

Under IC 32-31-3-12, the 45-day rule applies to all residential lease terminations, including early mutual terminations. There is no exemption for mutually agreed early terminations. The lease effectively terminated when the tenant delivered possession on April 10. The 45-day deadline therefore expired on May 25. Since the landlord failed to return the deposit or provide an itemized statement by May 25, IC 32-31-3-13 mandates forfeiture of all deduction rights, and the landlord must return the full $1,500 deposit.

Answer Options
A
The landlord is correct because mutual early terminations are exempt from the 45-day rule under IC 32-31-3
B
The landlord must return the full deposit because the 45-day deadline passed on May 25, and the landlord forfeited all deduction rights
C
The landlord has until 45 days from June 30 to respond because the tenant's demand restarts the statutory clock
D
The landlord may still deduct damages because mutual terminations extend the deadline to 90 days under Indiana law

Why This Is the Correct Answer

Sign up free to unlock full analysis

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Sign up free to unlock full analysis

Deep Analysis of This Practice Of Real Estate Question

Sign up free to unlock full analysis

Background Knowledge for Practice Of Real Estate

Sign up free to unlock full analysis
Sign up free to unlock full analysis

Real World Application in Practice Of Real Estate

Sign up free to unlock full analysis

Common Mistakes to Avoid on Practice Of Real Estate Questions

Sign up free to unlock full analysis

Related Topics & Key Terms

Key Terms:

security_depositlandlord_tenantearly_terminationforfeiture45_day_ruleic_32_31_3

Related Concepts

A tie-in arrangement is an illegal antitrust practice in which a seller conditions the purchase of one product or service on the buyer's agreement to purchase a separate product or service.

A trust account, also called an escrow account, is a separate bank account maintained by a broker to hold funds belonging to others, such as earnest money deposits, security deposits, or other client funds.

Advertising regulations govern how real estate licensees may market properties and services, requiring truthful, non-deceptive advertising that includes proper identification of the brokerage.

Was this explanation helpful?

More Practice Of Real Estate Questions

People Also Study

Related Articles

Practice More Questions

Access 2,000+ practice questions and pass your real estate exam.

Start Practicing