A subcontractor agreement includes a pay-when-paid clause. The owner becomes insolvent and cannot pay the general contractor. What is the likely legal effect of this clause?
Correct Answer
A) The clause may be interpreted as pay-if-paid, shifting risk to the subcontractor
Courts often interpret pay-when-paid clauses as pay-if-paid clauses in cases of owner insolvency, meaning the subcontractor bears the risk of non-payment. The specific contract language and jurisdiction determine the exact interpretation.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Courts frequently interpret pay-when-paid clauses as pay-if-paid clauses when the owner becomes insolvent, effectively shifting the risk of non-payment from the general contractor to the subcontractor. This interpretation means that if the owner never pays due to insolvency, the subcontractor may never receive payment. The exact interpretation depends on the specific contract language and the jurisdiction's legal precedents. This protects general contractors from bearing the financial burden of owner insolvency while placing that risk on subcontractors.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option B: The subcontractor can file a lien against the owner only
While subcontractors may have to wait for payment, the clause doesn't create an indefinite waiting period - it may actually eliminate the payment obligation entirely if interpreted as pay-if-paid, meaning no payment is ever required if the owner doesn't pay.
Option C: The subcontractor must wait indefinitely for payment
While subcontractors may have lien rights, this option doesn't address the primary legal effect of the pay-when-paid clause itself, which is the potential shift of non-payment risk to the subcontractor regardless of lien availability.
Memory Technique
Think 'Insolvent Owner = IF not WHEN' - insolvency changes the payment condition from a timing issue (when) to a conditional requirement (if)
Reference Hint
Florida Construction Law chapter on subcontractor agreements and payment clauses, or Contract Law sections covering conditional payment terms
More Contract Admin Questions
A project experiences a 30-day delay due to unusually severe weather. The contract includes a liquidated damages clause of $1,000 per day for delays. If the weather delay is excusable but not compensable, what liquidated damages apply?
A commercial project requires a total of 12 inspections. The building department charges $85 per inspection for the first 5 inspections, $65 for inspections 6-10, and $45 for any additional inspections. What is the total inspection fee?
What document must be posted at the job site before a Certificate of Occupancy can be issued for a commercial building?
A mixed-use development requires a variance for reduced setbacks. The property is located within 500 feet of a hospital. What additional consideration must be addressed?
A LEED project requires tracking of regional materials. Materials are considered regional if they are extracted, harvested, or recovered, as well as manufactured within what distance of the project site?
An indemnification clause in a construction contract typically requires the contractor to:
A property owner wants to convert a single-family home into a duplex in an area zoned for single-family residential use. The conversion meets all building codes but violates density requirements. What approval is needed?
As-built drawings are typically required to be submitted:
AIA Document A401 is primarily used for:
A general contractor is building a 12,000 square foot commercial warehouse. The building permit fee is calculated at $8.50 per $1,000 of construction value. If the project value is $2,400,000, what is the building permit fee?
People Also Study
Business & Financial Management
120 questions · 70% to pass
Project Management
60 questions · 70% to pass