A Louisiana contractor completes a $45,000 residential addition project. The homeowner pays $38,000 but disputes the final $7,000, claiming defective work. Under Louisiana Civil Code, what is the contractor's best legal remedy?
Correct Answer
D) File a mechanics lien for $7,000 and pursue breach of contract
The contractor can file a lien for the unpaid portion ($7,000) and separately pursue breach of contract claims for the disputed work under Louisiana Civil Code.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Under Louisiana law, the contractor's best remedy is to file a materialman's/contractor's lien (statement of claim) for the unpaid amount ($7,000) under the Louisiana Private Works Act, and simultaneously pursue a breach of contract claim if the owner's defect allegations are unfounded. Filing the lien preserves the contractor's security interest in the property while the dispute is resolved.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: File a mechanics lien for the full $45,000
Filing a lien for the full $45,000 is improper because $38,000 has already been paid. A lien may only be filed for the amount actually owed and unpaid. Filing a lien for an amount already received could constitute an abuse of the lien process.
Option B: Wait for the homeowner to cure the alleged defects
Waiting for the homeowner to cure alleged defects gives up the contractor's initiative. The homeowner is withholding payment, not offering to fix anything. The contractor should protect their payment rights legally rather than waiting passively.
Option C: Immediately sue for the full contract amount
Immediately suing for the full contract amount ($45,000) ignores that $38,000 has already been paid. A lawsuit for the full amount when partial payment was received would be incorrect and potentially frivolous as to the paid portion.
Memory Technique
Lien = Lock on the unpaid amount only. Lock the $7,000 with a lien, then fight the defect claim in court separately. Never lien what you've already been paid.
More Louisiana Questions
A contractor in Louisiana completes $85,000 worth of work on a residential project. The owner pays $70,000 but disputes the remaining $15,000. If the contractor files a lien claim, what percentage penalty can be awarded if the contractor prevails in court?
A contractor discovers contaminated soil during excavation that requires special disposal. The disposal cost is $12,000, and transportation is $3,500. If this was not foreseeable from the contract documents, who typically bears this cost under Louisiana law?
A construction worker is injured on a Louisiana job site. The contractor's workers' compensation carrier has 15 days to investigate. If they don't respond within this period, what happens to the claim?
Under Louisiana law, what is the minimum amount of workers' compensation insurance coverage required for construction contractors?
A contractor's employee is injured on a job site in Louisiana. The contractor has workers' compensation insurance. Which statement is correct regarding the employee's rights?
Under Louisiana Civil Code, if a building contract does not specify a completion date, when is the work considered to be due?
Under Louisiana building codes, what is the minimum width required for emergency egress windows in bedrooms?
A Class B contractor in Louisiana wants to bid on a project worth $175,000. What action must they take?
A contractor's worker is injured and files for workers' compensation. The injury occurred due to the worker's intoxication. Under Louisiana law, what is the likely outcome?
A general contractor discovers contaminated soil during excavation for a commercial project in Louisiana. Which state agency must be notified?
People Also Study
Business & Financial Management
120 questions · 70% to pass
Contract Administration
60 questions · 70% to pass
Project Management
60 questions · 70% to pass
Related Study Resources
Previous Question
A contractor's license expires on December 31st. If renewal is submitted on January 15th, what additional requirement must be met under R.S. 37:2150?
Next Question
A homeowner in Louisiana wants to sue a contractor for defective work completed 8 years ago. The defects were just discovered last month. Can the homeowner file suit?