A borrower is offered lender-paid mortgage insurance at 6.875% or borrower-paid at 6.375% with a $148 monthly premium. What does the rate difference mean for LPMI, and can the borrower later remove that rate premium using HPA cancellation rights?
Correct Answer
C) The 0.50-percentage-point rate premium is not removable through HPA borrower-paid PMI cancellation
C. HPA borrower-paid PMI cancellation does not remove the LPMI rate premium. The quoted rates differ by 6.875% − 6.375% = 0.50 percentage points. LPMI commonly carries a higher rate; the Act’s borrower-paid cancellation and automatic termination provisions do not apply to it. Scope and exceptions: LPMI ends when the mortgage is refinanced, paid off or otherwise terminated. Compare total costs using loan amount, term, expected holding period and potential BPMI cancellation; $148 alone does not settle which choice is cheaper. Source: FDIC Consumer Compliance Examination Manual V-5.1, Homeowners Protection Act: exclusions and LPMI disclosures (12 U.S.C. 4905) — https://www.fdic.gov/system/files/2024-06/v-5-1.pdf 12 U.S.C. 4905(a)–(c) — https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2024-title12/html/USCODE-2024-title12-chap49.htm
Why This Is the Correct Answer
C is correct because under the FDIC Consumer Compliance Examination Manual V-5.1, Homeowners Protection Act: exclusions and LPMI disclosures (12 U.S.C. 4905), the borrower-paid cancellation and automatic termination provisions do not apply to lender-paid mortgage insurance. The quoted rates differ by 6.875% - 6.375% = 0.50 percentage points, and that higher rate is how the LPMI cost is carried. Because 12 U.S.C. 4905(a)–(c) excludes lender-paid mortgage insurance from the HPA cancellation and termination provisions (sections 4902 through 4904), the borrower cannot use those rights to remove the rate premium later. It ends only when the mortgage is refinanced, paid off or otherwise terminated.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: LPMI is always cheaper, since the lender absorbs the insurance premium
A is wrong because it says LPMI is always cheaper since the lender absorbs the insurance premium. The tempting misconception is that "lender paid" means free to the borrower, but LPMI usually results in a higher interest rate, here 6.875% versus 6.375%. The $148 monthly premium alone does not settle which choice is cheaper; loan amount, term, expected holding period and potential BPMI cancellation must be compared.
Option B: The 2 are identical in cost, because the premium is simply repriced
B is wrong because it says the 2 options are identical in cost because the premium is simply repriced. The misconception is that moving the cost into the rate makes the two choices equivalent. The rate premium of 0.50 percentage points cannot be canceled by the borrower, while borrower-paid insurance could be canceled or automatically terminated, so the costs can diverge over time.
Option D: The 0.50-percentage-point rate premium automatically disappears at 80% loan-to-value
D is wrong because it claims the 0.50-percentage-point rate premium automatically disappears at 80% loan-to-value. The misconception is applying borrower-paid PMI rules to LPMI. Under 12 U.S.C. 4905, the cancellation and termination sections do not apply to LPMI, which ends only on refinance, payoff or other termination of the mortgage.
Deep Analysis of This Question
This question tests the difference between borrower-paid and lender-paid mortgage insurance and who can end each one. Under the FDIC Consumer Compliance Examination Manual V-5.1, Homeowners Protection Act: exclusions and LPMI disclosures (12 U.S.C. 4905), sections 4902 through 4904 do not apply to LPMI. Borrower-paid PMI can be canceled on request when the borrower meets the listed conditions and can terminate automatically. LPMI is typically paid through a higher rate, so the 0.50-point difference stays in the loan. The correct comparison is total cost, not the $148 premium alone.
Background Knowledge
The statute defines lender paid mortgage insurance as private mortgage insurance whose payments are made by a person other than the borrower. Before or at loan commitment, the lender must give written notice that LPMI may not be canceled by the borrower, while borrower-paid insurance could be cancelable and could automatically terminate. The notice also says LPMI usually results in a higher interest rate and terminates only when the mortgage is refinanced, paid off, or otherwise terminated.
Memory Technique
LPMI: Locked in the Rate: Think "Lender pays, Locked in the rate." With LPMI, the cost is locked into the higher rate (6.875% vs 6.375%), so the HPA cancel and terminate tools do not reach it. Only refinance, payoff or other termination ends it.
When an answer choice mentions removing or dropping the insurance on an LPMI loan, recall "locked in the rate" and reject any cancellation or automatic-termination option. Pick the choice that says HPA borrower-paid cancellation does not apply.
Exam Tip
Questions like this often tempt you with "lender pays, so it is cheaper" or with the idea that the higher rate automatically disappears at 80% loan-to-value (option D). Remember that HPA cancellation and termination rights belong to borrower-paid PMI, not LPMI.
Real World Application
A borrower asks an originator to compare a 6.875% LPMI loan with a 6.375% loan carrying a $148 monthly premium. The originator explains that the 0.50-point rate difference stays on the LPMI loan and cannot be canceled by the borrower. The originator notes that the borrower-paid option could be canceled or terminate later. Together they weigh the loan amount, term and how long the borrower expects to keep the loan.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Assuming LPMI is always cheaper because the lender pays the premium
- -Believing the higher LPMI rate drops off automatically at 80% loan-to-value
- -Judging the options by the $148 monthly premium alone without comparing total cost over the holding period
Key Terms
Source
FDIC Consumer Compliance Examination Manual V-5.1, Homeowners Protection Act: exclusions and LPMI disclosures (12 U.S.C. 4905) — https://www.fdic.gov/system/files/2024-06/v-5-1.pdf
12 U.S.C. 4905(a)–(c) — https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2024-title12/html/USCODE-2024-title12-chap49.htm
More Mortgage Knowledge Questions
Two years into a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage with an escrow account, the borrower's total monthly payment rises by $85. What is the most likely cause?
For a 1–4 unit home, Garn-St Germain bars the lender from enforcing a due-on-sale clause upon all of the following transfers EXCEPT:
A higher-priced first-lien loan with required escrow closed 3 years ago. The borrower is current and owes 74% of original value. When may the servicer cancel escrow at his request?
A lender requires a loan policy of title insurance for its $340,000 loan. The buyer has $85,000 of equity in the property. Does the lender's title policy insure the buyer's equity?
Under the 2007 Subprime Statement, which is cited as a typical mitigating factor that can justify a stated-income loan to a subprime borrower?
A small creditor's balloon-payment QM keeps that QM status if sold to an investor without small-creditor status how long after consummation?
In a mortgage loan, which recorded document creates the lien that secures the borrower's promise to repay the debt?
Under Reg X, a person that renders origination services and closes the loan in its own name in a table-funded transaction is a:
In the interagency nontraditional mortgage guidance, a loan feature commonly called “low doc/no doc” or “stated income” is known as:
An investor owns several rental houses, each financed with a conventional loan that requires private mortgage insurance. How do the Homeowners Protection Act's PMI cancellation and termination requirements apply to these loans?
People Also Study
Federal Mortgage-Related Laws
24% of exam
Mortgage Loan Origination Activities
27% of exam
Ethics, Fraud & Consumer Protection
18% of exam
Uniform State Test Content
11% of exam
Related Study Resources
Previous Question
The 2006 interagency guidance on nontraditional mortgage product risks applies to all of the following products EXCEPT:
Next Question
An ARM note sets the rate at the 30-day average SOFR plus a 2.75 margin, with SOFR at 4.10 on the adjustment date. What is the fully indexed rate before applying any contractual adjustment caps?
