P&CNew Yorkmedium
A NY P&C producer at a community event hands out branded $5 keychains to all attendees without conditioning the gift on purchasing a policy. Under NY Ins. Law § 2324 and DFS guidance, this is MOST likely:
AA per se violation of § 2324 regardless of value
Permissible as a de minimis promotional item not conditioned on policy purchase
CPermissible only if approved in advance by DFS
DPermissible only if the producer also files a rate amendment
Why this is the answer
NY Ins. Law § 2324 prohibits rebates 'as inducement to purchase' P&C insurance. DFS guidance recognizes a narrow de minimis exception for branded promotional items — keychains, pens, calendars — distributed broadly and not conditioned on a policy purchase. Two key elements: (1) the item's value is small (typically under $25 per recipient per year under DFS guidance) and (2) the giveaway is not tied to a specific transaction. A $100 gift card conditioned on binding a policy fails both prongs and is a clear violation; a $5 branded keychain handed to everyone at a parade satisfies both.
Studying for the New York Property & Casualty exam?
This question comes from our P&C bank. Take a free practice test — no signup.