EstatePass
L&HCaliforniahard

A multi-state employer offers California employees two medical options: (1) a Blue Shield HMO and (2) a Blue Shield PPO indemnity plan. An employee in the PPO plan is denied coverage for a specialty drug and wants to file a regulatory complaint. Which California regulator should the employee contact, and under what authority?

ADMHC under Knox-Keene, because all Blue Shield managed-care products are licensed as HMOs regardless of plan design
BEither DMHC or CDI, because California expressly permits the consumer to file a dual complaint with both
CDI under the California Insurance Code, because a PPO indemnity plan is disability insurance regulated by CDI
DCMS, because all employer-sponsored health plans fall under federal ERISA preemption with no state remedy

Why this is the answer

Even where a single carrier (Blue Shield, Blue Cross, Anthem, etc.) issues both HMO and PPO products, regulatory jurisdiction follows the product, not the carrier. The PPO indemnity product is 'disability insurance' under Ins. Code § 106 — CDI regulates rates, forms, and consumer complaints. The HMO is a 'health care service plan' under Health & Safety Code § 1345 — DMHC regulates it under Knox-Keene. ERISA preempts STATE LAW remedies in some employer-plan disputes but does not eliminate the state regulator's jurisdiction over the insurance product itself — and the question asks who to contact regulatorily, not who to sue.

Studying for the California Life & Health exam?

This question comes from our L&H bank. Take a free practice test — no signup.