EstatePass
Practice Of Real Estate DisclosuresTransfer_disclosure_statementHARD

A California seller sells a two-unit duplex. On the Seller Property Questionnaire the seller marks 'No' to the question asking whether any insurance claims have been filed on the property in the past five years. In fact the seller filed a water damage claim two years earlier and was paid $15,000. The buyer discovers the claim history after closing. What is the seller's potential liability?

Correct Answer

B) Liability for negligent misrepresentation if the seller genuinely forgot, or fraud if the omission was intentional

A seller must disclose facts that materially affect the value or desirability of the property, and a paid water damage claim is such a fact whether it surfaces on the statutory Transfer Disclosure Statement or on a supplemental form such as the Seller Property Questionnaire, which is where the insurance claims question actually appears. A false written answer exposes the seller to liability, and the seller's state of mind decides which claim the buyer has: negligent misrepresentation where the seller should have known and answered carelessly, fraud or intentional concealment where the seller knew and chose to hide it. Fraud carries the broader remedies, including rescission and punitive damages. Completed repairs do not erase the duty, and the buyer's ability to investigate does not excuse a false statement.

Answer Options
A
No liability, because insurance claims are private financial matters and not part of a seller's disclosures
B
Liability for negligent misrepresentation if the seller genuinely forgot, or fraud if the omission was intentional
C
Liability only if the water damage was never fully repaired before the sale
D
No liability, because the buyer could have ordered the property's CLUE claims report

Why This Is the Correct Answer

A seller must disclose facts that materially affect the value or desirability of the property, and a paid water damage claim is such a fact whether it surfaces on the statutory Transfer Disclosure Statement or on a supplemental form such as the Seller Property Questionnaire, which is where the insurance claims question actually appears. A false written answer exposes the seller to liability, and the seller's state of mind decides which claim the buyer has: negligent misrepresentation where the seller should have known and answered carelessly, fraud or intentional concealment where the seller knew and chose to hide it. Fraud carries the broader remedies, including rescission and punitive damages. Completed repairs do not erase the duty, and the buyer's ability to investigate does not excuse a false statement.

Interactive lesson · Chapter 23 of 30 · Disclosures and environmental hazards

Seller disclosures and the agent's duty

A patent defect is one a reasonable inspection would reveal; a latent defect is hidden from one. Sellers must disclose known material latent defects, and many states require a seller's disclosure statement, whose form and coverage state law sets. An agent must disclose material defects it knows of to the buyer, whoever its client is, and must not misrepresent the property. An "as is" clause means the buyer takes the condition it can see or was told about; it does not excuse concealment or fraud. A stigmatized property (one where a death, a crime or a similar event occurred) has no physical defect: state law sets whether the stigma must be disclosed.

Patent defectLatent defectSeller's disclosure statementStigma
Known material latent defects must be disclosedAn agent discloses known material defects, whoever its client is"As is" does not excuse concealment or fraud
Patent and latent defects, and the disclosure statement

Chapters 1–3 are free in full, practice sets included.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Deep Analysis of This Practice Of Real Estate Disclosures Question

Background Knowledge for Practice Of Real Estate Disclosures

Memory Technique

Exam Tip for Practice Of Real Estate Disclosures

Real World Application in Practice Of Real Estate Disclosures

Common Mistakes to Avoid on Practice Of Real Estate Disclosures Questions

Related Topics & Key Terms

Key Terms:

TDSinsurance_claimsmisrepresentationfraudnegligence

Related Concepts

The Lead-Based Paint Disclosure is a federally mandated disclosure required for all residential properties built before 1978. Sellers and landlords must disclose known lead-based paint hazards and provide the EPA pamphlet "Protect Your Family From Lead in Your Home."

A material defect is a condition that significantly affects the value, desirability, or safety of a property and that would likely influence a reasonable buyer's decision to purchase or the price they would pay.

Megan's Law requires states to make information about registered sex offenders available to the public. Some states require real estate agents to inform buyers about the availability of sex offender registries.

Was this explanation helpful?

More Practice Of Real Estate Disclosures Questions

People Also Study

Related Articles

Practice More Questions

Access 2,000+ practice questions and pass your real estate exam.

Start Practicing