EstatePass
Property Valuation Financial AnalysisCost_approachHARD

A Malibu coastal property has a land value of $3,500,000 and depreciated improvements of $250,000, yielding a cost approach indication of $3,750,000. Comparable sales, however, suggest a value of $4,200,000. What does this $450,000 discrepancy MOST likely indicate?

Correct Answer

D) The land value may be understated, or the market is recognizing an intangible location premium such as ocean views, coastal scarcity, and lifestyle appeal that the cost approach cannot capture

The cost approach derives value by adding land value to depreciated improvement cost. In premium coastal markets like Malibu, this additive method frequently underestimates value when the land estimate does not fully reflect buyer premiums — ocean views, scarcity of buildable coastal lots, and lifestyle desirability. When sales consistently exceed the cost approach indication, it signals either that land value is understated or that the land estimate has not fully reflected location attributes that can be included in market land value. This is a recognized limitation of the cost approach in highly desirable, land-value-dominant markets.

Answer Options
A
The sales comparison approach is unreliable because coastal comparable sales are too limited to produce a credible value indication
B
The depreciated cost of improvements has been overstated, inflating the cost approach result above its true indication
C
The appraiser should weight the cost approach more heavily because land value is objectively measurable in coastal markets
D
The land value may be understated, or the market is recognizing an intangible location premium such as ocean views, coastal scarcity, and lifestyle appeal that the cost approach cannot capture

Why This Is the Correct Answer

The cost approach derives value by adding land value to depreciated improvement cost. In premium coastal markets like Malibu, this additive method frequently underestimates value when the land estimate does not fully reflect buyer premiums — ocean views, scarcity of buildable coastal lots, and lifestyle desirability. When sales consistently exceed the cost approach indication, it signals either that land value is understated or that the land estimate has not fully reflected location attributes that can be included in market land value. This is a recognized limitation of the cost approach in highly desirable, land-value-dominant markets.

Interactive lesson · Chapter 5 of 30 · Valuation and CMA adjustments

Which way to adjust

Adjust the comparable's sale price to what it would have sold for if it matched the subject. A feature the comparable has and the subject lacks is subtracted; a feature the subject has and the comparable lacks is added.

$200k$400kComp sold− garageAdjusted

Set the garage adjustment so the comparable indicates $390,000 for the subject.

Comp sold $410,000− − garage $15,000= Adjusted $395,000
The comp is better: subtract

Chapters 1–3 are free in full, practice sets included.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

Deep Analysis of This Property Valuation Financial Analysis Question

Background Knowledge for Property Valuation Financial Analysis

Memory Technique

Exam Tip for Property Valuation Financial Analysis

Real World Application in Property Valuation Financial Analysis

Common Mistakes to Avoid on Property Valuation Financial Analysis Questions

Related Topics & Key Terms

Key Terms:

reconciliationcoastal_premiumland_dominancemalibucost_approach_limitations

Related Concepts

TILA is a federal law that requires lenders to disclose the true cost of credit to borrowers, including the annual percentage rate (APR), total finance charges, and loan terms. It is implemented by Regulation Z.

A trustee sale is a type of foreclosure where a trustee, appointed under a deed of trust, sells the property at auction to satisfy the debt.

Usury is the practice of charging an interest rate that exceeds the maximum rate permitted by state law. Usury laws protect borrowers from excessive interest charges on loans.

Was this explanation helpful?

More Property Valuation Financial Analysis Questions

People Also Study

Related Articles

Practice More Questions

Access 2,000+ practice questions and pass your real estate exam.

Start Practicing