In Texas, a broker's fiduciary duties to a client include all of the following EXCEPT:
Audio Lesson
Duration: 2:35
Question & Answer
Review the question and all answer choices
Loyalty
Loyalty is a core fiduciary duty requiring the agent to act in the client's best interest above all others, including the agent's own financial interests, and is firmly established under Texas agency law.
Obedience
Obedience is a recognized fiduciary duty that requires the agent to follow all lawful instructions given by the client, reflecting the principal-agent relationship's foundational requirement that the agent act as directed.
Guaranteeing profit
Disclosure
Disclosure is a critical fiduciary duty obligating the agent to inform the client of all material facts relevant to the transaction, including information about the property, the parties, and any conflicts of interest, and is explicitly required under Texas law.
Why is this correct?
Guaranteeing profit is not a fiduciary duty because fiduciary obligations govern how an agent behaves — with loyalty, honesty, and skill — not what financial outcomes they must produce, since market results are inherently uncertain and outside any agent's control. The recognized fiduciary duties in Texas real estate agency are loyalty, obedience, disclosure, confidentiality, accounting, and reasonable care (often remembered by the acronym OLDCAR), none of which include promising or guaranteeing a specific financial return. Imposing a duty to guarantee profit would be both legally unenforceable and commercially unreasonable, as it would require agents to warrant outcomes determined by market forces.
Deep Analysis
AI-powered in-depth explanation of this concept
Fiduciary duties in real estate agency relationships represent the highest standard of care that one party can owe to another, rooted in trust and confidence. In Texas, these duties — codified under TREC rules and the Texas Occupations Code — are designed to protect clients from self-dealing, negligence, and conflicts of interest by their agents. The reason 'guaranteeing profit' is excluded from fiduciary duties is fundamental: an agent cannot control market conditions, buyer behavior, or economic forces, and imposing a duty to guarantee outcomes would create an impossible and unjust standard that would expose agents to unlimited liability for factors beyond their control. Fiduciary duty governs the quality of the agent's conduct and loyalty, not the certainty of financial results.
Knowledge Background
Essential context and foundational knowledge
The concept of fiduciary duty in real estate agency evolved from common law principles of trust and agency that date back centuries in English law, where courts recognized that agents holding positions of trust must prioritize their principals' interests. In Texas, the modern framework for real estate fiduciary duties was formalized through the Texas Occupations Code (Chapter 1101) and TREC's agency rules, which were significantly updated in the 1990s as dual agency and buyer representation became more prevalent. The OLDCAR acronym — Obedience, Loyalty, Disclosure, Confidentiality, Accounting, and Reasonable Care — became a standard teaching framework used in Texas pre-licensing education to help agents memorize their core duties. The exclusion of 'guaranteeing profit' has always been implicit in the common law understanding that fiduciary duties govern conduct, not outcomes.
Podcast Transcript
Full conversation between instructor and student
Instructor
Hey there, let's dive into today's question about agency law in Texas. How are you doing with this topic so far?
Student
I'm doing okay, but I'm a bit confused about fiduciary duties. Can you give me a quick rundown of what we're looking at today?
Instructor
Absolutely. In Texas, a broker's fiduciary duties to a client are crucial. They include loyalty, obedience, confidentiality, disclosure, accounting, and care. Today's question is asking us to identify which of these duties a broker does NOT have.
Student
Got it. So, we're looking for the duty that's not a part of a broker's fiduciary responsibilities. The question options are loyalty, obedience, guaranteeing profit, and disclosure. Which one is the correct answer?
Instructor
That's a great question. The correct answer is C, guaranteeing profit. Brokers cannot promise financial outcomes because real estate markets are unpredictable and subject to many factors beyond their control. It's important to understand that while loyalty, obedience, and disclosure are fiduciary duties, guaranteeing profit is not.
Student
Oh, I see. So, it's not about the broker's control over the market, but more about the ethical and legal boundaries of their responsibilities?
Instructor
Exactly. Brokers must act in their clients' best interests, but they cannot make guarantees about the financial outcome. This is a common mistake, though, because it's tempting to think brokers should be able to promise a profit.
Student
I see, and what about the other options? Why are loyalty, obedience, and disclosure considered fiduciary duties?
Instructor
Loyalty means brokers must prioritize their client's interests above their own, avoiding conflicts of interest. Obedience requires brokers to follow their clients' lawful instructions, though not illegal ones. And disclosure is about revealing all material facts that could affect the client's decision, like property defects or agency relationships.
Student
That makes sense. So, how can I remember these fiduciary duties for the exam?
Instructor
A great memory technique is to use the acronym LOCDAC, which stands for Loyalty, Obedience, Confidentiality, Disclosure, Accounting, and Care. It's a quick way to recall the core duties without having to think too hard.
Student
That's a fantastic tip! Thanks for breaking it down for me. I'll definitely use that acronym to study.
Instructor
You're welcome! Remember, when you're faced with questions about fiduciary duties, just think of LOCDAC and you'll be set. Keep up the good work, and you'll do great on the exam. Good luck!
Use the acronym OLDCAR to remember the six Texas fiduciary duties: Obedience, Loyalty, Disclosure, Confidentiality, Accounting, and Reasonable Care — picture an OLD CAR that your agent drives carefully and honestly on your behalf. Notice that 'profit guarantee' is not part of the car — you can't guarantee the road conditions (the market), only how well you drive (your conduct). Any time you see 'guarantee' in an answer choice for a fiduciary duty question, it's almost certainly the EXCEPT answer.
Remember that fiduciary duties start with LOCDAC. Any duty not in this acronym, like guaranteeing profit, is not a fiduciary responsibility.
On 'EXCEPT' questions about fiduciary duties, immediately scan all answer choices for anything that sounds like a guaranteed financial outcome or a promise about market results, as these are never fiduciary duties. The word 'guaranteeing' is a strong signal that an answer choice is the exception, because fiduciary duties are about conduct and loyalty, not promised results. Memorizing the OLDCAR acronym will allow you to quickly verify which duties are legitimate and identify the outlier.
Real World Application
How this concept applies in actual real estate practice
A Texas seller hires a listing agent and asks her to sell the home for at least $450,000. The agent diligently markets the property, discloses all known material defects, follows the seller's instructions on open houses, and presents all offers promptly — fulfilling her fiduciary duties of loyalty, obedience, disclosure, and reasonable care. However, due to a sudden rise in interest rates, the best offer received is $420,000. The agent has fully met her fiduciary obligations even though the seller did not achieve their target price, because the agent's duty was to perform with skill and loyalty, not to guarantee a specific sales price. If the agent had promised in writing to guarantee a $450,000 sale, that promise would be unenforceable and potentially constitute misrepresentation.
Continue Learning
Explore this topic in different formats
More Agency Law Episodes
Continue learning with related audio lessons
Ohio's continuing education requirement for license renewal is:
2:14 • 35 plays
Ohio real estate licensees are regulated by the:
2:50 • 26 plays
A seller's agent in Texas owes which duty to buyers?
2:47 • 0 plays
South Dakota requires how many hours of pre-license education?
3:18 • 0 plays
Which Illinois agency fiduciary duty survives beyond the end of an agency relationship?
2:16 • 0 plays
Ready to Ace Your Real Estate Exam?
Access 2,500+ free podcast episodes covering all 11 exam topics.