Which of the following represents a violation of appraiser independence under the Dodd-Frank Act provisions?
Correct Answer
C) A loan officer asking an appraiser to consider additional comparables to support the contract price
Requesting that an appraiser consider additional comparables specifically to support a predetermined value (contract price) constitutes inappropriate influence and violates appraiser independence requirements.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
CORRECT_ANSWER - Option C represents a clear violation because the loan officer is asking the appraiser to find comparables specifically to support the contract price, which is a predetermined value. This constitutes inappropriate influence on the appraiser's independent professional judgment. The request implies that the current analysis doesn't support the contract price and asks the appraiser to find data to justify a specific outcome. This type of pressure to reach a predetermined conclusion is exactly what Dodd-Frank independence provisions were designed to prevent.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: An AMC selecting an appraiser from its approved panel
AMCs selecting appraisers from approved panels is a standard, legitimate practice that doesn't violate independence. The Dodd-Frank Act actually encourages the use of AMCs as intermediaries to create separation between lenders and appraisers. As long as the selection is based on objective criteria like competency, experience, and availability rather than willingness to hit certain values, this practice maintains independence.
Option B: A loan officer requesting a rush delivery for an additional fee
Requesting rush delivery for an additional fee is an administrative matter that doesn't influence the appraiser's valuation conclusion. While appraisers should ensure they have adequate time for proper analysis, requesting expedited service with appropriate compensation doesn't constitute pressure on the value opinion. This is a legitimate business arrangement regarding timing and fees, not value influence.
Option D: A lender requiring specific report format requirements
Requiring specific report formats is an administrative requirement that doesn't influence the appraiser's value conclusion. Lenders have legitimate needs for standardized reporting formats for their underwriting and quality control processes. As long as the format requirements don't restrict the appraiser's ability to provide necessary explanations or disclosures, this doesn't violate independence provisions.
VALUE PRESSURE Test
V-alue specific requests, A-sking for predetermined outcomes, L-eading toward contract price, U-ndue influence on conclusions, E-xpectations of specific results = PRESSURE that violates independence. Administrative matters (timing, format, additional data without value direction) = OK.
How to use: When evaluating potential independence violations, ask: 'Is this request trying to influence my VALUE conclusion or is it purely administrative?' If it mentions supporting a specific price or suggests a desired outcome, it's likely a violation.
Exam Tip
Look for key phrases like 'support the contract price,' 'make the deal work,' or 'consider additional comparables to justify' - these indicate value pressure and independence violations.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- -Thinking all requests for additional comparables are violations
- -Confusing administrative requirements with value influence
- -Not recognizing subtle pressure tactics that reference contract prices or deal requirements
Concept Deep Dive
Analysis
The Dodd-Frank Act established strict appraiser independence requirements to prevent the influence and pressure that contributed to the 2008 financial crisis. These provisions prohibit any attempts to influence an appraiser's professional judgment or predetermined value conclusions. The key distinction is between legitimate administrative requests (formatting, timing, additional data) versus attempts to influence the appraiser's valuation conclusion. Any communication that suggests a desired outcome or asks the appraiser to support a specific value violates independence requirements.
Background Knowledge
The Dodd-Frank Act's appraiser independence provisions were enacted in response to widespread appraisal pressure during the mortgage crisis. These rules prohibit any attempts to influence appraisers to reach predetermined values while allowing legitimate administrative communications. Understanding the difference between administrative requests and value influence is crucial for compliance.
Real-World Application
In practice, appraisers regularly receive requests for additional comparables or analysis, which is acceptable. However, when these requests are tied to supporting a specific value or making a transaction work, they cross the line into prohibited influence. Appraisers must document any inappropriate pressure and may need to withdraw from assignments where independence is compromised.
More Report Writing Questions
Under FIRREA, which federal agency has the authority to set minimum standards for real estate appraisals in federally related transactions?
What is the minimum transaction threshold for requiring a state licensed or certified appraiser under Title XI for most federally related transactions?
The Dodd-Frank Act established which requirement specifically related to appraisal independence?
Which of the following is NOT a responsibility of the Appraisal Subcommittee (ASC)?
State appraiser regulatory agencies are primarily responsible for which of the following functions?
People Also Study
Valuation Principles & Procedures
25% of exam
Property Description & Analysis
20% of exam
Market Analysis & Highest/Best Use
15% of exam
Appraisal Math & Statistics
15% of exam
USPAP (Ethics & Standards)
15% of exam
Related Tools
Previous Question
A state regulatory agency discovers that an appraiser has been consistently violating USPAP standards. The agency's investigation reveals a pattern of negligent practices over two years. What action can the state agency take?
Next Question
In a narrative appraisal report, which section should contain the appraiser's final reconciliation and value conclusion?