In Texas, a comparative market analysis (CMA) can be prepared by:
Audio Lesson
Duration: 3:18
Question & Answer
Review the question and all answer choices
Only licensed appraisers
Restricting CMAs to licensed appraisers is incorrect because a CMA is not a formal appraisal; it is a market-based pricing opinion that falls within the authorized scope of services for all Texas real estate licensees, including agents.
Licensed real estate agents
Only brokers
Limiting CMA preparation to brokers only is incorrect because Texas law grants this authority to all real estate licensees, including sales agents operating under a sponsoring broker's supervision.
Attorneys only
Attorneys are not trained in real estate valuation methodology and are not authorized under Texas law to prepare CMAs as a standard professional service; this option has no basis in Texas real estate statute or TREC rules.
Why is this correct?
Under Texas law and TREC regulations, licensed real estate agents (as well as brokers) are authorized to prepare CMAs as a standard component of their brokerage services, such as advising sellers on listing prices or helping buyers evaluate offers. A CMA is not considered an 'appraisal' under Texas law and therefore does not require an appraiser's license, provided the licensee does not represent the CMA as a formal appraisal. This is consistent with the Texas Appraiser Licensing and Certification Act, which reserves the term 'appraisal' for credentialed appraisers but explicitly allows licensees to provide opinions of value in the ordinary course of their real estate business.
Deep Analysis
AI-powered in-depth explanation of this concept
A Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) is a professional opinion of value based on recently sold comparable properties, and it serves a fundamentally different legal purpose than a formal appraisal. Texas law distinguishes between a CMA, which is a sales tool used by licensees to assist clients in pricing decisions, and a licensed appraisal, which is a regulated valuation product required for mortgage lending under FIRREA (Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989). This distinction exists to protect consumers by ensuring that high-stakes financial decisions — such as securing a mortgage — rely on the objective analysis of a credentialed appraiser, while still allowing real estate professionals to provide market-based pricing guidance. The Texas Occupations Code and TREC rules permit licensees to prepare CMAs as part of their ordinary brokerage services without crossing into the unauthorized practice of appraisal.
Knowledge Background
Essential context and foundational knowledge
The legal distinction between a CMA and a formal appraisal was crystallized at the federal level by FIRREA in 1989, which mandated that federally related mortgage transactions use state-certified or licensed appraisers following the Savings and Loan crisis, during which inflated property valuations contributed to massive institutional failures. States like Texas subsequently enacted their own appraiser licensing acts to comply with federal standards while carving out an explicit exception for real estate licensees providing opinions of value in the course of their brokerage duties. Over time, TREC has reinforced through its rules and guidance that CMAs are a legitimate and expected service from agents and brokers, provided they are not misrepresented as certified appraisals. This framework balances consumer access to market information with the rigorous protections required for mortgage lending.
Podcast Transcript
Full conversation between instructor and student
Instructor
Hey there, welcome back to the Real Estate License Exam Prep Podcast. Today, we're diving into a question that's a bit of a no-brainer but still important to understand. It's about who can prepare a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) in Texas.
Student
Oh, that sounds interesting! I've heard of CMAs, but I'm not sure who's actually allowed to prepare them.
Instructor
Exactly. The question is: "In Texas, a comparative market analysis (CMA) can be prepared by:" and it gives us four options. Let's go through them quickly.
Student
Okay, let's hear them. What are the options?
Instructor
Option A says "Only licensed appraisers," B is "Licensed real estate agents," C is "Only brokers," and D is "Attorneys only."
Student
So, which one is it?
Instructor
The correct answer is B, "Licensed real estate agents." Now, let's break down why that's the right choice.
Student
Sure, I'm listening.
Instructor
Well, a CMA is an informal estimate of a property's value based on recently sold, similar properties in the area. It's not a formal appraisal, which requires specific education, experience, and licensing. CMAs are considered brokerage services under Texas law.
Student
That makes sense. So, why is it that only licensed real estate agents can prepare them?
Instructor
Because licensed real estate agents, working under their broker, can prepare CMAs as part of their normal duties. They analyze comparable properties to help clients determine appropriate listing prices or make informed offers.
Student
Oh, I see. So, it's not just brokers who can do it?
Instructor
No, it's not. While brokers can certainly prepare CMAs, the question is specifically asking who can prepare them. Licensed agents can do it too, as long as they're working under a broker.
Student
Got it. And what about the other options? Why are they wrong?
Instructor
Option A is wrong because only licensed appraisers can prepare formal appraisals, not CMAs. Option C is incorrect because it suggests brokers are the only ones who can prepare CMAs, when agents can do it as well. And option D is just flat-out wrong because attorneys have no special authority to prepare CMAs under Texas real estate law.
Student
I see the distinction now. So, how do we remember this?
Instructor
Great question. Think of a CMA like a weather forecast and an appraisal like a meteorological instrument reading. A weather forecaster (real estate agent) can predict likely market conditions using available data, while only a certified meteorologist (appraiser) can operate specialized equipment to provide officially certified measurements.
Student
That's a great analogy! It really helps clarify the difference.
Instructor
Exactly. And remember, for questions about who can prepare valuation documents, remember: CMAs = agents and brokers; appraisals = only licensed appraisers. Look for keywords like 'formal' or 'certified' which typically indicate an appraisal is required.
Student
Thanks for the tip, that'll definitely help on the exam.
Instructor
You're welcome! And remember, practice makes perfect. Keep studying, and we'll see you next time on the Real Estate License Exam Prep Podcast. Good luck!
Remember the phrase 'Agents Analyze, Appraisers Appraise' — a CMA is an Analysis done by Agents, while a formal Appraisal requires a licensed Appraiser. Think of a CMA as a 'market snapshot' any licensee can take with their MLS camera, while an appraisal is a 'certified portrait' that only a credentialed appraiser can paint for the bank.
When you see a question about who can prepare valuation documents, ask yourself: Is this a forecast (CMA) or a certified measurement (appraisal)?
On the Texas real estate exam, whenever a question involves who can prepare a CMA versus who must conduct a formal appraisal, focus on the end use: CMAs are for pricing guidance (agents and brokers), while formal appraisals are for mortgage lending (licensed appraisers only). Watch for answer choices that use the word 'only,' as they are frequently designed to trap test-takers into overly restrictive answers.
Real World Application
How this concept applies in actual real estate practice
A homeowner in Austin, Texas, contacts a licensed real estate agent to discuss selling her home. The agent visits the property, reviews recent sales of comparable homes in the neighborhood using MLS data, and prepares a detailed CMA showing that similar 3-bedroom homes have sold between $420,000 and $445,000 in the past 90 days. Based on the CMA, the agent recommends a listing price of $435,000, and the seller lists the home. When the buyer later applies for a mortgage, the lender orders a formal appraisal from a state-certified appraiser — a separate, independent process entirely distinct from the agent's CMA.
Continue Learning
Explore this topic in different formats
More Valuation & Appraisal Episodes
Continue learning with related audio lessons
All of the following affect real estate values in subsequent years, except:
2:41 • 8 plays
The appraisal approach that estimates value by comparing a property to similar recently sold properties is the:
2:41 • 0 plays
What type of depreciation is the most challenging to correct?
3:28 • 0 plays
An important characteristic of land is that it may be modified or improved. Such improvements tend to increase the value of real estate. Which of the following is NOT an improvement?
2:07 • 0 plays
In Florida, the sales comparison approach is most commonly used for:
3:15 • 0 plays
Ready to Ace Your Real Estate Exam?
Access 2,500+ free podcast episodes covering all 11 exam topics.