A New York broker's fiduciary duties include all EXCEPT:
Audio Lesson
Duration: 2:53
Question & Answer
Review the question and all answer choices
Loyalty
Loyalty is a core fiduciary duty requiring the broker to place the client's interests above all others, including the broker's own financial interests, and is explicitly recognized under New York agency law — making it an incorrect answer to a question asking what is NOT a fiduciary duty.
Full disclosure
Full disclosure is a recognized fiduciary duty requiring the broker to disclose all material facts known to them that could affect the client's decisions, including conflicts of interest, and is codified in New York's agency disclosure requirements under Real Property Law Section 443 — making it an incorrect answer here.
Guaranteeing sale price
Confidentiality
Confidentiality is a fiduciary duty requiring the broker to protect sensitive client information — such as the client's motivation to sell quickly or their maximum offer price — from being disclosed to adverse parties, and is a fundamental component of the OLD CAR framework taught in New York pre-licensing education.
Why is this correct?
Under New York Real Property Law and the principles established by the New York Department of State's licensing regulations, a broker's fiduciary duties are limited to loyalty, confidentiality, disclosure, obedience, reasonable care, and accounting — collectively known by the acronym OLD CAR. Guaranteeing a sale price is not a fiduciary duty because it would constitute a promise about a future market outcome, which no agent can legally or ethically make, and doing so could constitute fraudulent misrepresentation under New York General Business Law.
Deep Analysis
AI-powered in-depth explanation of this concept
Fiduciary duties in a real estate agency relationship are legally enforceable obligations that an agent owes to their principal, rooted in the law of agency and designed to ensure the agent acts in the client's best interest rather than their own. The prohibition on guaranteeing outcomes — such as sale price or closing timeline — exists because real estate markets are inherently unpredictable, and any such guarantee would expose the broker to fraudulent misrepresentation claims and would create unrealistic expectations that distort the client's decision-making. A broker's role is to exercise professional skill and judgment, not to warrant results, and New York courts have consistently held that outcome guarantees fall outside the scope of legitimate agency duties. This distinction protects both the public from deceptive promises and the broker from liability for market forces beyond their control.
Knowledge Background
Essential context and foundational knowledge
New York's formal codification of broker fiduciary duties evolved significantly with the passage of Real Property Law Section 443, which established mandatory agency disclosure requirements in the 1990s in response to widespread consumer confusion about whom the broker actually represented. Before this legislation, many buyers mistakenly believed their agent was working for them when the agent was legally a subagent of the seller. The OLD CAR framework — Obedience, Loyalty, Disclosure, Confidentiality, Accounting, and Reasonable Care — became the standard teaching tool following these reforms and is now the foundation of New York's agency law curriculum.
Podcast Transcript
Full conversation between instructor and student
Instructor
Alright, let's dive into today's question. How are you feeling about it, by the way?
Student
I'm a bit nervous. It's about agency law, and I'm not sure I completely grasp fiduciary duties yet.
Instructor
That's perfectly normal. The question is: "A New York broker's fiduciary duties include all EXCEPT:" and the options are A. Loyalty, B. Full disclosure, C. Guaranteeing sale price, and D. Confidentiality. Do you know what the correct answer is?
Student
I think it's either A or D because they both sound like fiduciary duties. But I'm not sure about guaranteeing the sale price.
Instructor
Exactly. This question is testing your understanding of fiduciary duties in real estate agency relationships. It's a fundamental concept, and it's crucial to know it well. Let's break it down.
Student
So, what are fiduciary duties?
Instructor
Fiduciary duties are the ethical and legal foundation of the broker-client relationship. They include loyalty, full disclosure, confidentiality, and accountability. Brokers must act in their clients' best interests, but they can't guarantee outcomes like sale prices.
Student
Got it. So, the correct answer is C because brokers can't guarantee the sale price?
Instructor
Absolutely. While brokers must be loyal, disclose all material facts, and maintain confidentiality, they cannot control market conditions or buyer decisions. Guaranteeing the sale price would be unethical and potentially illegal.
Student
Oh, I see. I made that mistake before. I thought brokers could control everything, including the sale price.
Instructor
Many students do. It's important to remember that brokers can control their actions and communications but not the market forces or third-party decisions.
Student
So, why are A, B, and D the correct answers?
Instructor
Let's go through them quickly. A, Loyalty, is a core fiduciary duty, meaning brokers must prioritize their client's interests above all others. B, Full disclosure, is also crucial; brokers must reveal all material facts that could affect the client's decision-making process. And D, Confidentiality, is a must because brokers must protect sensitive client information.
Student
Got it. I'll remember that brokers can't guarantee outcomes but must adhere to loyalty, disclosure, and confidentiality.
Instructor
That's right. A great way to remember the main fiduciary duties is by using the acronym LODC: Loyalty, Obedience, Disclosure, Confidentiality.
Student
LODC, got it. Thanks for explaining this. I feel more confident now.
Instructor
You're welcome! Remember, when you encounter questions about fiduciary duties, think about actions and obligations, not outcomes. And always keep LODC in mind. You've got this!
Use the acronym OLD CAR to remember New York broker fiduciary duties: Obedience, Loyalty, Disclosure, Confidentiality, Accounting, and Reasonable Care. Notice that 'Guarantee' does not appear anywhere in OLD CAR — if it's not in the car, it's not part of the ride, and a broker who promises guaranteed prices has driven off the road.
Remember that LODC duties apply to brokers, but they cannot control outcomes. If an option promises a guaranteed result, it's not a fiduciary duty.
Questions asking for the 'EXCEPT' or 'NOT' format require you to identify the one item that does not belong — in fiduciary duty questions, always run through OLD CAR mentally and check whether each answer choice appears in that list. Any answer that involves promising a specific market outcome will always be the 'NOT a duty' answer, because brokers sell skill, not certainty.
Real World Application
How this concept applies in actual real estate practice
A New York listing broker tells a seller, 'I guarantee your home will sell for at least $850,000 within 60 days.' This statement is not only outside the broker's fiduciary duties but could expose the broker to a misrepresentation claim if the home sells for less or takes longer. A properly acting broker would instead say, 'Based on current comparable sales and market conditions, I believe a listing price of $850,000 is appropriate, but I cannot guarantee the final sale price or timeline because those depend on buyer activity and market conditions.'
Continue Learning
Explore this topic in different formats
More Agency Law Episodes
Continue learning with related audio lessons
Ohio's continuing education requirement for license renewal is:
2:14 • 3 plays
Ohio real estate licensees are regulated by the:
2:50 • 26 plays
A seller's agent in Texas owes which duty to buyers?
2:47 • 0 plays
South Dakota requires how many hours of pre-license education?
3:18 • 0 plays
Which Illinois agency fiduciary duty survives beyond the end of an agency relationship?
2:16 • 0 plays
Ready to Ace Your Real Estate Exam?
Access 2,500+ free podcast episodes covering all 11 exam topics.