A credit scoring model includes 'years at current address' as a significant factor. Analysis reveals this criterion results in lower scores for 25% of Native American applicants compared to 8% of white applicants, due to cultural patterns of extended family housing arrangements. The model developer argues residential stability predicts creditworthiness. This scenario most likely represents:
Correct Answer
C) Disparate impact that requires business necessity justification
This represents disparate impact under the Fair Housing Act and ECOA. While the criterion appears neutral, it disproportionately affects Native Americans due to cultural housing patterns. The model developer must prove that 'years at current address' is necessary for accurate credit assessment and that no alternative method exists that would be less discriminatory while achieving the same predictive accuracy.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
This represents disparate impact under the Fair Housing Act and ECOA. While the criterion appears neutral, it disproportionately affects Native Americans due to cultural housing patterns. The model developer must prove that 'years at current address' is necessary for accurate credit assessment and that no alternative method exists that would be less discriminatory while achieving the same predictive accuracy.
More Ethics & Fraud Questions
A lender's mobile app prominently displays a 'pre-qualification' feature that asks for minimal information but generates loan amount estimates that are consistently 20-30% higher than what borrowers actually qualify for when they complete full applications. The app includes a disclaimer that estimates are 'subject to full underwriting.' This practice is most likely:
An MLO discovers that multiple loan applications from different borrowers contain identical handwriting in the signature sections, despite different purported signers. The applications were submitted by different real estate agents. What is the most appropriate immediate action?
A mortgage loan originator receives a lead from a real estate agent about a potential borrower. Before calling this consumer, the MLO must:
An MLO tells Asian applicants that they need larger down payments 'because that's what investors prefer for your type of loan,' while telling similarly qualified white applicants that standard down payments are acceptable. This practice represents:
A mortgage company advertises 'Guaranteed approval for all credit types!' but internally has minimum credit score requirements of 580. This advertisement is problematic because it:
People Also Study
Federal Mortgage-Related Laws
23% of exam
General Mortgage Knowledge
23% of exam
Mortgage Loan Origination Activities
25% of exam
Uniform State Test Content
12% of exam
Previous Question
A bank's loan committee consistently approves white applicants at a 90% rate but only approves Black applicants at a 60% rate, despite similar credit profiles. When questioned, committee members deny any racial bias and claim decisions are based solely on credit factors. This pattern suggests:
Next Question
A loan officer discovers that a borrower has provided false employment verification documents. The borrower explains they recently lost their job but expect to find new employment soon and just need the loan to keep their family housed. How should this be classified?