A commercial property appraisal using the income approach shows a significant variance from the cost approach value. The building is 15 years old and well-maintained. What is the most likely explanation for this variance?
Correct Answer
B) There is external obsolescence affecting the property
External obsolescence, such as changes in the neighbourhood, economic conditions, or market demand, would cause the income approach to show lower values than the cost approach. Since the building is well-maintained, physical deterioration is unlikely, and external factors affecting rental income and property desirability are the most probable cause of the variance.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
External obsolescence, such as changes in the neighbourhood, economic conditions, or market demand, would cause the income approach to show lower values than the cost approach. Since the building is well-maintained, physical deterioration is unlikely, and external factors affecting rental income and property desirability are the most probable cause of the variance.
Deep Dive: Understanding the Answer
External obsolescence, such as changes in the neighbourhood, economic conditions, or market demand, would cause the income approach to show lower values than the cost approach. Since the building is well-maintained, physical deterioration is unlikely, and external factors affecting rental income and property desirability are the most probable cause of the variance.
This question tests your understanding of Property Valuation concepts that are commonly assessed on Canadian real estate licensing exams. The correct answer, “There is external obsolescence affecting the property”, reflects a fundamental principle that real estate professionals in Canada must understand.
Specifically, this falls under the sub-topic of Appraisal Methods, which is an important area within Property Valuation that appears regularly on provincial licensing exams across Canada.
About Property Valuation
Appraisal methods (comparison, cost, income), market analysis, and factors affecting property value.
Property Valuation is one of the core areas covered on Canadian real estate licensing exams, including RECO (Ontario), BCFSA (British Columbia), and RECA (Alberta). Understanding these concepts is essential for anyone pursuing a career in Canadian real estate.
Study Tips for Property Valuation
- •Master all three appraisal approaches: comparison, cost, and income.
- •Understand how the GRM (Gross Rent Multiplier) and Cap Rate are calculated.
- •Know the factors that affect highest and best use analysis.
- •Review how the MPAC assessment process works in Ontario.
More Property Valuation Questions
Which of the following is the most appropriate valuation approach for a single-family residential property in a well-established neighborhood with many recent sales?
What is the primary purpose of a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) in real estate practice?
Which factor would have the LEAST direct impact on a residential property's market value?
In the cost approach to valuation, what does the term 'depreciation' refer to?
An appraiser is valuing a 15-unit apartment building. The building generates $180,000 in annual rental income with operating expenses of $60,000. If the capitalization rate for similar properties is 8%, what is the estimated value using the income approach?
- → When conducting a CMA, which of the following properties would be considered the BEST comparable for a 1,800 sq ft bungalow built in 1985?
- → Which of the following scenarios would most likely result in functional obsolescence in a residential property?
- → In Ontario, what is the key difference between an appraisal and a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA)?
- → An appraiser is using the cost approach to value a custom-built heritage home. The reproduction cost new is estimated at $850,000, the land value is $300,000, and total depreciation is calculated at $180,000. What is the property's estimated value using this approach?
- → A commercial property appraiser is reconciling three different approaches that yielded the following values: Direct Comparison $2,100,000, Cost Approach $2,400,000, Income Approach $1,950,000. Given that this is an income-producing office building in a market with limited sales but strong rental data, which approach should receive the greatest weight in the final value estimate?
- → Which appraisal method is most appropriate when valuing a unique heritage property with no comparable recent sales?
- → In conducting a Comparative Market Analysis (CMA), which property characteristic typically has the greatest impact on value adjustments?
- → When using the income approach to value a rental property, what does the capitalization rate represent?
- → A real estate agent is preparing a CMA for a 2,000 square foot bungalow. A comparable property sold for $450,000 but has an additional 300 square feet. If the adjustment is $150 per square foot, what is the adjusted sale price of the comparable?
- → Which factor would most likely cause a property's value to decrease in a market analysis?
People Also Study
Real Property Law
60 questions
Contracts & Agreements
60 questions
Agency & Professional Ethics
60 questions
Mortgage & Real Estate Finance
60 questions
Helpful Resources
Previous Question
A commercial property analysis shows three recent sales: $2.1M, $2.3M, and $1.9M for similar properties. However, the $1.9M sale was a distressed sale due to foreclosure. For valuation purposes, how should this data be treated?
Next Question
A commercial property appraiser is reconciling three different approaches that yielded the following values: Direct Comparison $2,100,000, Cost Approach $2,400,000, Income Approach $1,950,000. Given that this is an income-producing office building in a market with limited sales but strong rental data, which approach should receive the greatest weight in the final value estimate?