Sarah lists her home with ABC Realty under an exclusive listing agreement that expires on June 30th. On July 15th, she sells the property to a buyer who first viewed the home during an open house hosted by ABC Realty in May. Assuming a standard holdover clause exists, what is the likely outcome?
Correct Answer
B) ABC Realty is entitled to full commission due to the holdover clause
The holdover clause protects ABC Realty's commission rights because they introduced the buyer to the property during the active listing period, even though the sale closed after expiry. This prevents sellers from avoiding commission by delaying sales until after listing expiration.
Why This Is the Correct Answer
Option B is correct because the holdover clause specifically protects ABC Realty's commission rights when a buyer they introduced during the active listing period purchases the property after expiry. Since the buyer first viewed the home at ABC Realty's open house in May (during the active listing), and purchased in July (within the typical holdover period), ABC Realty demonstrated the necessary causal connection between their marketing efforts and the eventual sale. Standard holdover clauses in Canadian listing agreements typically provide 30-90 days of protection post-expiry for such scenarios.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
Option A: ABC Realty has no claim to commission since the listing expired
This is incorrect because it ignores the holdover clause protection. The listing agreement's expiry doesn't automatically terminate all commission obligations when the brokerage can prove they introduced the eventual buyer during the active period. Holdover clauses are standard provisions that extend commission rights beyond the listing expiry date for buyers who had meaningful contact with the property through the listing brokerage's efforts.
Option C: Sarah owes half commission to ABC Realty
This is incorrect because holdover clauses typically entitle the brokerage to full commission, not partial commission. When the conditions of a holdover clause are met (buyer introduced during active period, purchase within holdover timeframe), the brokerage has earned the full commission as originally agreed. There's no standard provision for reducing commission to half in holdover situations.
Option D: The buyer must pay ABC Realty's commission
This is incorrect because commission obligations are contractual arrangements between the seller and listing brokerage, not the buyer. Buyers are not parties to listing agreements and have no legal obligation to pay the listing brokerage's commission. The seller remains responsible for commission payments even when holdover clauses apply, as this was part of their original listing agreement.
Deep Analysis of This Contracts & Agreements Question
This question tests understanding of holdover clauses in exclusive listing agreements, a critical protection mechanism for real estate brokerages. The holdover clause (also called protection period) ensures that if a buyer who was introduced to the property during the active listing period purchases the property within a specified timeframe after listing expiry, the brokerage still earns commission. This prevents sellers from circumventing commission obligations by deliberately delaying closings until after listing expiration. The clause typically extends 30-90 days post-expiry and only applies to buyers who had meaningful contact with the property through the listing brokerage's efforts. This concept is fundamental to understanding how listing agreements protect brokerage interests while maintaining fair market practices. It balances seller rights with legitimate brokerage expectations for compensation when their marketing efforts directly result in a sale.
Background Knowledge for Contracts & Agreements
Holdover clauses (protection periods) are standard provisions in exclusive listing agreements that extend commission rights beyond the listing expiry date. They typically last 30-90 days and apply when buyers who had meaningful contact with the property during the active listing period purchase within the holdover timeframe. The clause must clearly identify qualifying buyers and specify the protection period duration. This protects brokerages from sellers who might delay closings to avoid commission. Under provincial real estate legislation like TRESA (Ontario) and RESA (Alberta), these clauses must be clearly disclosed and agreed upon in writing.
Memory Technique
The HOLD PrincipleH - Holdover protects the brokerage, O - Original contact during active period, L - Listing expired but protection continues, D - Deal closes within protection timeframe. Think of it like 'holding onto' commission rights even after the listing 'lets go' (expires).
When you see questions about sales after listing expiry, apply HOLD: check if there was Original contact during the active period, and if the Deal closed within the holdover timeframe. If both conditions are met, the brokerage HOLDs onto their commission rights.
Exam Tip for Contracts & Agreements
Look for two key elements in holdover questions: (1) buyer contact during active listing period, and (2) sale within typical holdover timeframe (usually 30-90 days post-expiry). If both exist, the brokerage keeps full commission rights.
Real World Application in Contracts & Agreements
A listing expires on March 31st, and the seller decides not to renew. In May, a buyer who attended the brokerage's February open house contacts the seller directly and purchases the property. The listing agreement included a 60-day holdover clause. Despite the direct sale, the original listing brokerage is entitled to full commission because they introduced the buyer during the active period, and the sale occurred within the protection timeframe. This protects brokerages from sellers who try to avoid commission by encouraging buyers to wait until after expiry.
Common Mistakes to Avoid on Contracts & Agreements Questions
- •Assuming listing expiry automatically terminates all commission obligations
- •Thinking holdover clauses only apply to partial commission payments
- •Believing buyers are responsible for paying listing brokerage commissions
Key Terms
More Contracts & Agreements Questions
What is the primary purpose of an Agreement of Purchase and Sale (APS) in a real estate transaction?
In a listing agreement, what does the term 'holdover period' refer to?
Which of the following is NOT typically considered an essential element for a valid contract under Canadian common law?
When can a conditional offer become unconditional in a real estate transaction?
A buyer submits an offer with a financing condition that expires at 11:59 PM on Friday. The buyer's mortgage application is approved at 10:30 AM on Saturday. What is the legal status of the offer?
- → In Ontario, what is the significance of the 'irrevocable' period in an Agreement of Purchase and Sale?
- → A seller receives two offers on the same property. The first offer is conditional on financing, and the second is unconditional but for a lower price. What is the seller's best legal option?
- → What happens when a buyer waives a home inspection condition after discovering significant structural issues during the inspection?
- → In British Columbia, if a listing agent presents an offer to their seller client that contains an unusual clause they don't understand, what is their professional obligation?
- → A buyer's agent discovers that their client has been declared bankrupt but has not disclosed this information. The client wants to submit an offer on a property. What should the agent do?
- → What is the primary purpose of an Agreement of Purchase and Sale in a real estate transaction?
- → In a listing agreement, what does the term 'holdover period' refer to?
- → Which of the following is NOT typically considered an essential element for a valid contract under Canadian common law?
- → What happens when a condition in an Agreement of Purchase and Sale is not fulfilled by the specified deadline?
- → A buyer submits an offer with a financing condition that must be satisfied within 5 business days. On day 4, the buyer's mortgage application is approved but they want better terms. What can the buyer legally do?
People Also Study
Real Property Law
60 questions
Agency & Professional Ethics
60 questions
Mortgage & Real Estate Finance
60 questions
Land Use & Planning
50 questions
Helpful Resources
Previous Question
In Toronto, a property sells for $1,200,000. What is the total Land Transfer Tax payable (both provincial and municipal)?
Next Question
Sarah submits an offer on a property with a condition for home inspection to be completed within 7 days. On day 5, she decides she wants to remove this condition without conducting an inspection. What document should be used?